Power Outages Strike East Coast 1697
fordp writes "CNN, CNBC and others are reporting that major power outages are happening just after 4:00PM EDT in New York, New Jersey, Detroit, Ottawa and Toronto, Toledo." There are reports of a Con Edison transformer on fire on 14th Street in NYC, and lots of people stuck in trains and elevators. CNN is reporting that it is, according to power officials, most likely not related to terrorism, because you know you were wondering. The Niagra Mohawk power grid is overloaded, which feeds electricity throughout the northeast U.S. and into Canada. Update: 08/14 21:06 GMT by P : The mayor said there was no fire, that it was black smoke brought on by an automatic shutdown because of the power grid failure.
Come On Now.. Overreaction? (Score:3, Insightful)
I'm not one to say that we shouldn't worry a little, but coincidences happen! Why should we jump to conclusions long before anything really big has happened? Come on now, this is just way too much hype!! When they begin to find evidence of something bad happening, then tell me about power outages.
People stuck in elevators? Please. The power goes out everywhere, let's at least pretend that we're not shaking in our boots, and put some confidence back in our country!
Air conditioners? (Score:5, Insightful)
Nice to see that one failure can do this (Score:3, Insightful)
I find it really interesting that one overload in niagra falls area can do this to the power grid.
Why in the world is it engineered that way? to allow undersized power plants supply a city that overgrew it's power potential?
outages like this (Score:5, Insightful)
Right now, "officials" are saying this probably isn't terrorism. But I bet it's giving al-Qaeda some ideas.
If an accident can make this happen, I'm sure a cleverly-placed explosive can make it happen much more easily.
And once all those cities are out of power and essentially crippled, the real strikes start.
And now, if you'll excuse me, I have to go get some tea on for when the FBI guys come knocking on my door. Does Ashcroft take one lump or two?
Re:Nice to see that one failure can do this (Score:1, Insightful)
Re:Come On Now.. Overreaction? (Score:3, Insightful)
If they said "There is no evidence of Terrorist attack" that would have caused panic, because everyone is just on egde from too many "Yellow/Orange" alerts. And they know it.
Perhaps they could have worded it "It appears to be an unplanned outage..." but they had to use the "T" word for dramatic effect.
Re:Central Boston not affected (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Nice to see that one failure can do this (Score:1, Insightful)
They're just deregulating the electicity market here in Holland, so commercial entities can now compete for customers instead of electricity production being managed by the government. Our infrastructure is a lot better (small country, so you can easily interconnect everything and have redundant lines, and it's linked into the Europe-wide network too) but I hope they've got some good regulations set up to ensure a steady supply of electricity, and not just a cheap one...
Lourens
Re:Come On Now.. Overreaction? (Score:1, Insightful)
Well, YEAH, it's New York. Hell, they get 1" of snow, and all of a sudden the whole world is shut down.
Sorry, I live in Wisconsin, we don't shut down for 1" of snow, and I'm tired of their 'center of the world' mentality over there.
Re:Come On Now.. Overreaction? (Score:3, Insightful)
Don't be ridiculous. EVERYONE was wondering if there was a terrorist link, including you. Why tap dance around a question on everyone's mind, when you can address it directly?
Re:So what is that natural occurance? (Score:1, Insightful)
Re:On the other hand... (Score:1, Insightful)
Re:You know your a geek... (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Come On Now.. Overreaction? (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:Great Blackout of 2003 Caused by MSBlast Worm? (Score:4, Insightful)
Let's preview the baseless speculation that we'll likely hear in the next hour or so as 24-hour news pundits rush to scare the crap out of the public in their overzealous attempt to add more color to the simple news item that they intend to milk for all its worth over the next day:
* CNN interviews a taxicab driver whose cousin thinks this may be the work of Saddam Hussein
* Fox "confirms" the "terrorist attack" using as evidence, an unnamed "washington insider" noticing a dark-skinned man walking down the hallway of an unspecified building seconds prior to the outage.
* Red Cross is immediately planning "Power Aid 2003" featuring an all-new remake by Vicki Lawrence of "The Night the Lights Went Out in George" - proceeds of $100 billion are expected, $11.43 of which will actually be used to improve the power grid.
Re:Nice to see that one failure can do this (Score:4, Insightful)
Kind of like a domino effect.
The system is probably way too slow to handle (or predict?) near-by grid failures, which is why other grids are popping, too.
Re:Manhattan (Score:2, Insightful)
You're probably in the dark anyway, huh?
Re:And California? (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Come On Now.. Overreaction? (Score:5, Insightful)
No, I wasn't. I heard about this first here. My first thought was W32/Blaster. And I would have laughed...
I don't think terrorists are organised enough yet to pull something like this off. Just like SARS, West Nile, Mad Cow; I think terrorism is way over hyped. I think we need to be aware of them and deal with them, but drunk driving, not wearing seatblets and undercooked meat kill far more people, and are often overlooked.
Re:Why they porobably hate item/char/money auction (Score:2, Insightful)
The other problem a power outage causes is that the bacteria in the filter that do the bio-filtration will die during the power outage, and when the power restarts, all the waste will get pumped into the tank.
So, power an airstone from an UPS (or get a simple and cheap battery powered airpump), and break-down and clean the filter so that when it comes back on, it doesn't pollute the tank.
Re:American priorities MORE POWER NOW! (Score:4, Insightful)
Conserving power is ludicrous. There is an unlimited supply of power in the Universe. Why should we even *consider* conserving it?
We need MORE POWER NOW! I want cheaper, more reliable power. I want a nuclear plant next to my house, better yet, in my basement, for my own personal power usage.
Conserving water, makes sense, we only have so much h2O, although it'd be better to invest in purifying our current supply and recycling water.
So, again, WHY? WHY SHOULD WE CONSERVE POWER????? WHY WHY WHY????
my power bill is $180-200. I keep my house at 72-75F, even when it's 105F outside. IF the power company gets 35% more expensive here then it will be cost effective to generate my own using propane and a generator.
Well, Forget That... (Score:2, Insightful)
Forget that: It's not funny because we're in the middle of a serious heatwave, and these power outages are going to put large numbers of people, particularly the elderly, at risk. Electricity is far more vital to people's lives than, "It lets me read Slashdot."
Re:And California? (Score:4, Insightful)
Frankly, I think Cruz Bustamante would make a fine governor. Unfortunately, I think it's "hasta la vista, California."
Re:American priorities (Score:3, Insightful)
Stay the course.
Re:Air conditioners? (Score:2, Insightful)
Let's hope it gets cleared up soon.
- g
Silver Lining Re:On the other hand... (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:Can we see the evidence? (Score:3, Insightful)
Thats just the problem, I dont believe the news, the news is getting to be so far right of far left, that its too political to believe. I get my information from the internet.
I do not believe some gov official just because they say its so, I need evidence, I need to see an expert tell me what happened, not the mayor.
I actually dont get my news from NPR because I know its slanted just like fox news. Instead I actually gather my own evidence and decide for myself.
I dont understand why people get mad when a person asks questions about what happened. So its not terrorism? Well what is it?
IF the government is so clear that its not terrorism they should also be the first to tell us what exactly happened, or else they shouldnt make a statement at all until they KNOW what happened.
Re:IF it is the worm, who do we blame? (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:ALIENS ATTACKING WEST COAST!! (Score:1, Insightful)
what about parallel power? (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:On the other hand... (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:The Enron connection (Score:4, Insightful)
Construction and power production have been unionised for at least six decades. It does not seem that there has been a sudden change there.
There is quite a bit more regulation, but the main set of regulations that have affected capacity are the increased scrutiny of nuclear plants after the one at Three Mile Island came close to a melt-down. When idiots build a nuclear bomb upwind of Manhattan even a 1% chance that the station would go critical is too close to be acceptable.
The problem is that the nuclear industry lied repeatedly about its safety record. So now nobody can believe a word that is said by them.
I am actually prepared to support certain nuclear power designs. The heavy water system built by the Camadians and the MIT 'carbon ball' systems are both true failsafe systems. The light water and AGR systems built in the US, most of Europe and the USSR are all intrinsically unsafe, kept from catastrophic failure by a series of 'safety' systems. As the Challenger, Columbia and Chernobyl events showed, technologists are not as good at building risk free systems as they claim.
Re:On the other hand... (Score:5, Insightful)
Why are you so worried? You seem to be more afraid of each other, then other things!
Well, let me tell you a couple facts about major US cities. I figure it is probably true in urban areas in other countries, but I can't directly speak for them.
Before there was any hint of a power outage on the east coast, police who would be working tonight knew it could be a tough night. It was going to be hot and muggy tonight but no rain. People would be out on the streets because the houses and apartments without air conditioning would still be hot from the daylight hours. It is a summer Thursday night and a lot of people would be getting their weekend startend early. It is almost payday for a lot of people. Checks hit on Fridays or on the 15th of the month for most people. Usually, if you have direct deposit, they hit a day early. So you combine all these factors and you are going to see a rise in domestic disputes and general violence. Now, turn off the lights and everybody's air conditioning and you have just multiplied the problem. Now you have a lot of hot people without their nightly drug (TV) or the money they expected (ATMs are down) with nothing to do but interact with other hot, annoyed people. Smell trouble?
My other question is...isn't the 2nd Amendment about creating a mulitia to defend your country...not about defending your house?
The simple answer, without politics, is yes. But how do you define 'militia'? Historically, at the time it was written, it meant all able-bodied males between the ages of 18 and 45. When the militia was called upon, they were an irregular force used to suppliment or replace regular soldiers. Often, they would take over a fort or garrison when the regular troops were needed elsewhere. Usually, this meant defending their own homes, although the British in the colonies were known to pull the militia out to other areas and force the homes to be left undefended. This would have the effect of upsetting the militia.
When the militia was called up, they were expected to bring their own weapons and provisions, hence the need for keeping weapons in their homes and knowing how to use them. The Swiss use this method to this day.
And is it the gun culture of the USA that brings about this fear?
No, it is really the media that inspires this fear. When we wake up Friday morning, we are going to be shown every bad thing that happened overnight in the blackout areas. If there isn't major unrest, we will hear about 'heat-related deaths' and traffic accidents. That is the American media mentality. I guess it must be our own fault for watching all the trash we do. What you won't see covered are things that are going on right now in New York: People are buying food and water for strangers when the shop keepers aren't just giving it away for free. People are taking in their friends and coworkers and giving them a place to stay for the night if they can't get home. People are sharing their cell phones so strangers can call home and let their families know they are alright. I saw a man walking with candles to the houses of older members of his church to make sure they were alright and had what they needed to make it through the night. What is going on right now is the true American spirit and it crosses all racial, social and economic lines. And this is true of 99.99% of the people caught out in this mess tonight. The other 0.001% will be splashed across the front pages and news broadcasts around the world and people will wonder how terrible it must be to be in that situation.
And last, but not least, this is the night that will have a ripple effect throughout the entire area. No TV, nothing to do and the condom stores are closed? Expect a mini baby boom next May of 'black-out babies'!
Re:On the other hand... (Score:2, Insightful)
they aren't the same logic: the first, "A implies B" means that A is a sufficient condition for B to occur. The second, "B only if A" means A is a necessary condition for B to occur. A could be true but B still might not happen in the latter case.
-mantis
Re:To answer your questions (Score:4, Insightful)
A few major reasons. First and foremost, the Constitution was thought to be a document to goveron the nation for, at most, a generation or so. After that it would be scrapped, and rewritten as more appropiate to the times, (although I would be hard pressed to find something I like better). The Founding Fathers were concerned that THEY not some future despot would become drunk with power and try to oppress the people. Remember that we were less than ten years from a fairly bloody conflict with our (and your) parent nation.
The theory was that the people should have the ability (not necessarily the right) to overthrow the government, should it become necessary. Indeed history shows us that in most cases despots have first disarmed the populace:
The Founding Fathers had some very specific viewpoints about it as well.
There was legitimate fear that the government would become corrupt, and NEED to be overthrown because the people would be unable to remove the corrupt from power.
From our Declaration of Independence:
This is a small section of the document that many Americans actually feel is more important than the constitution. After all, there are several perfectly legitimate ways to organize a government. Furthermore, a constitution needs to change with the times.
Over the years how we have interpeted and taken this portion of the Declaration has changed. Now, we a
Report from TORONTO (Score:3, Insightful)
august 15, 2003 - 9:56am (toronto)
here in toronto, there are portions of the city getting power.
where i am (college and dovercourt), there is still no power.
this was a rare opportunity to observe a city of people
without electricity.
a report of what it was like being here -- actually quite nice.
its the first time i've ever been able to see the stars at night
from inside the streets of toronto. the moon is just past full,
and mars sits there like a jewel to her lower right, with the
whole glittering firmament behind her. it was quite beautiful.
around 4:15pm yesterday, we were all at work, when the screens
in front of our faces went dark, and a big gasp and then a golden
moment of silence, and you could just hear some birds chirp, and
no more fans. then people were wandering about aimlessly -- like
unplugged borg. there was no more point in carrying on, since we
need our machines to produce anything, so the crew was soon packed-up
to go home.
since it was nice weather, the patios along king street the
street lights were out, it was little use trying to get anywhere
by car, so people started walking. at the intersections, some
people were still using light-driven habits, and many others
quickly negotiated intersections by looking across with glances.
its amazing how well people keep going without with simply the
communication provided by LOOKING. i could finally understand
the traffic dispersal patterns of old black and whitee photos
taken in times before traffic lights -- people wandering an
intersection, and negotiating the passage by glances is really
a good experience.
Comforts that were rare among our forefathers are now
multiplied in factories and handed out wholesale; and indeed,
nobody nowadays, so long as he is content to go without air,
space, quiet, decency and good manners, need be without
anything whatever that he wants; or at least a reasonably
cheap imitation of it. (G. K. Chesterton)
of course, i wish all the best efforts towards those helping
those who were stuck in elevators, or had emergency situations.
most of us just went down the stairs. one of the programmers
used the light on his gameboy to get down the ten flights.
those in cars were especially afflicted with bad traffic getting home.
but the phones were working, the water is working, and the weather
is fine. a lot of people used this time to start talking with their
neighbours. if you had a case of beer (which couldn't be bought --
since all the tills need power), then you were lucky.
yes, it was strange to see lights out on abandoned and stopped
street-cars, but since things were actually quiet in the middle of
the city for the first time in memory -- you could hear things better,
and you could hear a lot of people talking, and socializing and
laughing with people in the backyards -- many of them lit with
candles. riding bike along bloor street, there was a fellow in a
darkened shop window selling candles with a transistor radio on,
and that's how we found out it was the whole east coast.
you ask, is it the building? the block, the city? progressively
the scope of the blackout became known as people called relatives
outside the zone.
also of note -- it is a lot cooler without the air-conditioners.
without all the air-conditioners drawing power and producing heat,
the overall general OUTDOOR air-temperature is much cooler,
and everything is quite nice. we still don't have power,
so i've not ventured to ride my bike in to work yet.
but right now, the sun is shining, there's no loud droning of
air-conditioners all over the place, you can hear the morning
winds in the trees wafting, and birds chirping, and neighbours
walking around outside talking with each other. i hear they
have power now a couple blocks over from my section in the
downtown core -- maybe i'll be able to dail-in to slashdot,
Re:On the other hand... (Score:2, Insightful)
Silly question. You don't keep them cold, you drink them.
Igor
Re:On the other hand... (Score:3, Insightful)
Ya know, it could be that people have their tinfoil hats on backwards, or maybe inside-out. If you turn it other way round, you should become properly paranoid about home accidents, and feel blissfully protected against being murdered in the park.
Re:Come On Now.. Overreaction? (Score:2, Insightful)
I thought it was called "humor" - you British Imperialist slimeballs lost your linguistic dominance several hundred years ago.
Firstly, if you had a decent global perspective you might realise that it's not only the British that spell 'humour' that way - squigglesquash could just as easily be Canadian, Australian, etc.
Secondly, if you had a decent grasp of history you would know that several hundred years ago, British English was the only widely-spoken form, and was dominant enough that an infant country called the United States of America adopted it (prior to Webster making official changes to its spelling for political reasons).