IT's Musical Habits 676
operand sent in a fun little article about the listening habits of IT. It seems that developers are headbangers, Microsoft certified pros are Britney fans, and management goes for Mozart. Tragically The Who is not included... Linux users tend toward Electronica, and Security goes for The Dead.
200 students? that's it? (Score:5, Insightful)
Wow, a poll of a whole 200 students...not exactly a big enough sample size for this study to be taken seriously...plus, what do the british know about music anyway...(oh, c'mon)...
How apt (Score:1, Insightful)
What's the point ? (Score:2, Insightful)
I thought the music that we listen too was more related to whom we listen to music with, so if you have a manager who grew in some Bronxesque area, he'd listen to the Ramones or Public Enemy rathger than to Mozart...
Oh, please (Score:1, Insightful)
This is about as useful as saying... (Score:3, Insightful)
I do agree that the functions of the brain that enable logical and organizational thinking somehow also enable either strong inclination for music or strong musical abilities. But to say that developers or *nix admins tend to like different kinds of music is going a bit far.
Comment removed (Score:3, Insightful)
The Fall (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:Britney is greatly underrated (Score:1, Insightful)
Re:Poetic... (Score:1, Insightful)
Oh, no. I'm sure a statistically meaningful survey classified 200 people into 7 groups, each of which turned out have entirely distinct, internally consistent, top 3 preferences!
Of course this stuff is made up!
Bach? (Score:3, Insightful)
But also considering the logical build-up of the music. Looking at friends and colleagues, I have a feeling that there are more Bach lovers among beta people than there are among alpha people.
Re:I must be the odd man out... (Score:1, Insightful)
The Dead (Score:4, Insightful)
While often simply dismissed musically as "hippie crap" and "meaningless poetic fluff," this is not what is important here.
What is important is that The Dead flies right in the face of the music industry.
You see, The Dead is often considered to be the most sucessful band in history, as they have played in front of more people then any group in musical history. Not only that, but each year the group (or whats left of them) makes millions in profits from various sales.
All the while giving away the vast majority of their music for free! [gdlive.com]
This is my favorite example of a "happy middle ground" that can be reached between bands and listeners. Sorry RIAA, your claims are false. And The Grateful Dead proves it.
Slight correction (Score:1, Insightful)
Have to be careful here with music tastes (Score:5, Insightful)
What is it with people. Can't anyone have likes and dis-likes in music? If someone says they don't like hip-hop, then people jump down their throats calling them small-minded, yet would a hip-hop fan sit down and listen to an album of Hank Williams Sr.? Or Patsy Cline?
Would a fan of opera actually spend his or her time going to the store to buy a Megadeth album? Life is too short, there are only so many hours in a persons life they can actually listen to and enjoy music...why waste it on stuff you don't like?
There is no one out there that likes every form of music there is, you may think you do, but trust me, there is always something out there that will make your skin crawl no matter what you like. If you like a particular style or genre of music, don't worry if someone else doesn't like it. Music is a personal thing.
People are different! Wow, what a concept!
Re:Heavy Metal, why am I not surprised? (Score:5, Insightful)
When you code 10-14 hours a day, I find it's nice to listen to something *not* coming out of a computer (well, ok, the sound *is* coming out of a computer, but way back once it actually came out of an analog instrument).
The beat is set by a human being, an undertuned 8-string guitar roars thru the distorted tube amplifier (ok and then it all goes into a 12-bit ADC, back and forth between different media and in the end comes out of speakers attached to a computer - but never mind the last part.) - see, that is the kind of music that gets me thru the day in front of the 22" CRT
Re:Have to be careful here with music tastes (Score:3, Insightful)
Well, by some chance, I happen to know that my wife's current collection of CDs in her car for the drives to/from work include Eminem and Patsy Cline. No Hank Williams Sr or Jr at the moment, but they are in the collection.
She has mentioned humming some of Eminem's songs (which often do have real melodies, unlike most rap) at meetings, and enjoying the grins of the few people who recognize them. This is in a medical IT environment, FWIW.
Re:Age profile (Score:3, Insightful)
Frankly, that survey seems lame, and wildly inaccurate at best.
I was a teenager when Green Day and the Offspring were all that. I couldn't like the Offspring any less.
Re:The Dead (Score:3, Insightful)
Let's also not forget the heavy drug use that was rampant at Dead shows. I don't think everyone would be groovin' out to a 20-minute song if the crowd was straight-edge.
The Grateful Dead are the exception, not the rule. I don't see many kids following punk bands around.
Re:Have to be careful here with music tastes (Score:3, Insightful)
There is only one type of music I won't listen to, and that's lazy, overproduced, low concept pop. If a person doesn't care enough to at least make the best, most interesting music they can regardless of their chosen stylistic patterns, I don't want to hear it.
Incidentally, the reason most hip-hop fans assume their opponents are closed minded is that most people who hate the music hate it solely on the wack bullshit they play on the radio. That boring, unlyrical crunk/pimp crap is not hip-hop, no matter what they tell you -- it's as much hip-hop as Britney is rock and roll, or Avril Lavigne is punk. An opinion based on these input media would be like basing your opinion on pastries on a pop tart, or basing your opinion on the outdoors on some swamp.
Re:Have to be careful here with music tastes (Score:5, Insightful)
All music is techno or electronica. (Score:3, Insightful)
Oh, you mean, electronic technology?
All music, even high, classical, concert or cult music (whatever name you want to use) nowadays is made using during its conposition, performance or both electronic technology.
I don't understand why you get so worked out about a niche genre whose most outstanding feature is the endles boring repetition of loops.
Re:Have to be careful here with music tastes (Score:3, Insightful)
Exhibit A: emacs v. vi
Exhibit B: Windows v. the world
Etc.
It is far easier to pass on the whole mess with the touchy-feely crap.
Re:Have to be careful here with music tastes (Score:3, Insightful)
There is absolutely nothing forbidding me from expressing likes and dislikes for specific hobbies, interests, worldviews, etc., etc. Everyone has these preferences. But when you start elevating your own predilections into some sort of fundamental moral truth, by ascribing your own preferences to "The Will of God" or "Scientific Truth" or "The Will of the People" or whatever euphemism you prefer for turning preferences into fact, then you're not showing "moral courage." You're simply proving that you're human for having preferences, and egotistical enough to consider them binding on everyone else.
Given the barrage of nonsensical and contradictory moral absolutes that bombard us every day, irony sounds comparatively pleasant.
Re:Have to be careful here with music tastes (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Have to be careful here with music tastes (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:200 students? that's it? (Score:2, Insightful)
apt but functionally poor analogy. Canada and the United States of America might share the same continent, but the whole world thinks "USA" when you say "America".
I am Canadian & you will never hear me call myself "American".