Annual Fee For Your Comment? 553
CaptainThunderbolt writes "Imagine this: you read an interesting story on Slashdot and you have a comment to make, so you login only to be greeted with a message saying you will need to pay a fee in order to make your comment. Seems ridiculous, doesn't it? Why on earth would you pay just to make a comment? Well, that is exactly how thousands of Aussies feel right now. AtomicMPC is an Australian PC Magazine with a fiercely loyal readership and an equally loyal online community. Yesterday it was announced that access to the most popular sections of the forum will soon attract a $20/year fee unless you are a magazine subscriber or a high-ranking forum member. The reaction to this announcement triggered the most vicious backlash I have ever witnessed as the website feedback forum went beserk. Users baulked at the idea of having to pay to access a community which the feel they are responsible for creating and I must say I understand how they feel. Is this a trend I should worry about? Will I one day have to pay a membership fee to access other popular forums?"
Hey, Subscribers! (Score:5, Funny)
IQ Test (Score:3, Funny)
FP!!! (Score:3, Funny)
(and it didn't cost me anything....)
Uh.. (Score:1, Funny)
Re:IQ Test (Score:5, Funny)
Sounds like poor planning (Score:3, Funny)
* Shrug *
Hindsight's 20/20, of course, but it seems obvious to me that you introduce fees in a formerly free setting by charging for new, premium services. To use Slashdot metaphors:
Re:Hey, Subscribers! (Score:5, Funny)
Re:fees happen (Score:5, Funny)
I can empathize with your stance you wouldn't want to provide profit (e.g., for slashdot) when you (and the community) are the providers of the content. But, in my opinion (and I don't know the economics of the posted article's site, nor do I know slashdot's), the fee requested or charged seems modest and I'm guessing it barely covers the cost of providing the systems, the bandwidth, etc. to support the forum. Again, I may be wrong about that, but I don't see this akin to gouging and submarining the user population.
On the other hand, were they (or slashdot) to ask something more like $20 A MONTH, I'd question their motive (as I question Microsoft's), and would probably step back and take a look as to whether I still considered posting on that forum at that price a "deal" I'm willing to take.
Again, market forces. Yes, we in many ways create and sustain communities like slashdot, but I know from experience putting something like this platform together, maintaining it, and sustaining ain't easy, and it ain't free. So, I'm willing to cut slashdot a little slackdot (even though it wasn't slashdot the original post points to -- just wanted to use the slackdot pun -- even though it was a bad one..)
Re:Like a $20 cover charge at a bar... (Score:4, Funny)
Re:IQ Test (Score:3, Funny)
Re:Let Capitalism run its course. (Score:5, Funny)
"Libratarians
I'm a Scorporiotarian --- what should I do??
Re:I agree with this (Score:3, Funny)
Re:Alternate Proposal (Score:5, Funny)
AborigiNeal?
Re:Let Capitalism run its course. (Score:3, Funny)
KFG
Re:Let Capitalism run its course. (Score:3, Funny)
"Bite me"
You meant to reply to the grandparent correct?
Re:You forgot 7.) (Score:3, Funny)
/. has nothing to do with it!!! (Score:1, Funny)
I think this massive surge in traffic is simply a testimony to the fabulous success of the new content and access model we have recently introduced."
Of course it is!
[snap] (Score:2, Funny)
Comment withheld due to lack of payment - slashdot team
Re:Let Capitalism run its course. (Score:1, Funny)
I'm a Scorporiotarian --- what should I do??
Yeah, I feel for you. I't must be tough finding work since they cancelled Farscape.
Re:Let Capitalism run its course. (Score:5, Funny)
...For the love of God, look out behind you!...
Oh, crap.
Re:Let Capitalism run its course. (Score:2, Funny)
Everything should be free, FREE I say!
Who isn't tired of these richy-rich magazine websites, sitting on their yacht, floating down the the advertising gravy river?
They should be paying their members for their glorious LOL- and IMO-laden comments.
How about sharing some of the bottomless cash cow that is the Australian PC Magazine Market???
I mean (AUS)$20 a YEAR?? For that much money you could put little Umbeki through College in Chad!
Better yet, you could fund the average Aussie's bar tab for 5 minutes!
The only reason I decided not to launch PCPerth Magazine is because absolute power corrupts absolutely!!!
Bastards.