Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
The Courts Government Media Music News Your Rights Online

RIAA Argues That MP3s From CDs Are Unauthorized 668

Posted by kdawson
from the no-fair dept.
NewYorkCountryLawyer writes "In an Arizona case against a defendant who has no legal representation, Atlantic v. Howell, the RIAA is now arguing — contrary to its lawyers' statements to the United States Supreme Court in 2005 MGM v. Grokster — that the defendant's ripping of personal MP3 copies onto his computer is a copyright infringement. At page 15 of its brief (PDF) it states the following: 'It is undisputed that Defendant possessed unauthorized copies... Virtually all of the sound recordings... are in the ".mp3" format for his and his wife's use... Once Defendant converted Plaintiffs' recordings into the compressed .mp3 format and they are in his shared folder, they are no longer the authorized copies...'"
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

RIAA Argues That MP3s From CDs Are Unauthorized

Comments Filter:
  • Re:This! (Score:5, Funny)

    by JorDan Clock (664877) <jordanclock@gmail.com> on Tuesday December 11, 2007 @04:21AM (#21652805)
    Madness? This. Is. AMERICA!!
  • by doktor-hladnjak (650513) on Tuesday December 11, 2007 @05:00AM (#21652993)
    Unless (and it is a big if) they are saying that possession of mp3s in his shared folder is an unauthorized format. But I can't quite follow that.

    Remember, these are RIAA lawyers we're talking about, not techies. What's the same format in different locations to you could be described entirely differently by these guys.
  • by squidinkcalligraphy (558677) on Tuesday December 11, 2007 @05:15AM (#21653057)
    I wonder what would happen if I left a CD in the drive, set up a folder of fifos which are the output of a rip-and-encode program that starts when the fifo is read, then share this folder in kazaa. This should squarely put the blame of copyright infringement on whoever is downloading...
  • by digitalcowboy (142658) on Tuesday December 11, 2007 @06:44AM (#21653437)
    Virtually all of the sound recordings... are in the ".mp3" format for his and his wife's use..

    RIAA Lawyer: Your honor, despite sharing a surname, bank account and residence, Plaintiff's exhibit 23A - a copy of a marriage license - will clearly show that Mr. Defendant and his so-called wife are, in fact, two completely separate people. Furthermore, these DNA samples, marked Plaintiff's exhibit 23B, also provide conclusive evidence that these two "married" people are most certainly two distinct persons.

    Our license to this music clearly states that it is for personal use. Copyright law makes clear that this only grants license to one person and yet the Defendant plainly admits that he illegally shared our copyrighted content with his so-called wife, a clearly separate and unauthorized entity.

    This is an outrageous, flagrant and willful disregard for the law! On that basis, I move for summary judgement.
  • by Tesen (858022) on Tuesday December 11, 2007 @07:58AM (#21653837)
    Well of course, you can't copy the music you purchased to your PC! Are you nuts?!? Just like, if you have a few friends around for a dinner party and play the music even from the original CD you're hosting a public performance of that music!!!(did you get permission to do that? No? Well tough!).

    You people! How dare you eat into my money! How dare you think, even just for a moment that the music you purchased allows you to convert it to MP3 for use on your iPod and PC!!! Damn it, if you want MP3's pay for it again in MP3 format from iTunes! I have stock in Apple as well you pricks! I want MORE MONEY!

    Oh and would some one please think of the artists! You are robbing them! Stealing from them! We already shaft them up the backside! They don't need a threeway going on! That is our job to fuck the artists! WILL SOMEBODY PLEASE THINK OF THE ARTISTS HERE!?!?! CAUSE WE WON'T!!!

    Fucking annoyed now because I can't buy my 12th house in Europe because you all copied music, not to even mention the penis enlargement surgery I had planned!

    RIAA Executive zombie #666
  • by Homr Zodyssey (905161) on Tuesday December 11, 2007 @10:17AM (#21654983) Journal

    I learned it was cool to listen to something that most others don't know about.

    I've been listening to the voices in my head for years and noone else seems to know about them. Wow! I must be extremely cool!

    Right now they're telling me I should seek out indie-music snobs and sacrifice them to the Space God Zorkon...

  • by NewYorkCountryLawyer (912032) * <ray.beckermanlegal@com> on Tuesday December 11, 2007 @11:08AM (#21655573) Homepage Journal

    I hate the RIAA as much as the next guy. However....
    Beware of posts that begin "I hate.... as much as the next guy. However......"
  • by Anonymous Coward on Tuesday December 11, 2007 @11:44AM (#21656085)
    Old but still funny :) http://www.deadtroll.com/video/digitalrage1.html [deadtroll.com]
  • by Nonillion (266505) on Tuesday December 11, 2007 @12:33PM (#21656991)
    Attention RIAA:

    What part of Go Fuck Yourself are you having a problem understanding? What part of Fair Use has sailed over your head? When I rip MY CD's on MY computer be it mp3, ogg or flac it's to do so for convenience. It would not be any different if I recorded my CD's to a Hi-Fi VCR or cassette deck. You can take your unauthorized copy bullshit and jam it squarely up your ASS.

If it's worth doing, it's worth doing for money.

Working...