Yoko Ono/EMI Suit Exposes Fair Use Flaw

Ian Lamont writes "Yoko Ono and EMI Records have backed down from their suit against the makers of a documentary film who used a 15-second fragment of a John Lennon song — but only after a Stanford Law School group got involved. Even though the use of the clip was clearly Fair Use, the case exposed a huge problem with the doctrine: It's becoming too expensive for people to actually take advantage of what is supposed to be a guaranteed right. Ironically, the song in question was Imagine."

Re:What's yellow and lives off dead beatles?

[eeyore]

Tsk, tsk it's an insectivorous submarine!

Comment removed

[account_deleted]

Comment removed based on user account deletion

She's right

[4D6963]

I hate to admit it, but she's right. Everybody knows that such types of fair-use are what make record sales plummet. Why buy John Lennon's record when you've got a 15-second fragment of one of his song in a documentary that you can just reply as many times as you like?

That's right, you don't, which is why so many baby seal-killing pirates are now resorting to listening to documentary soundtracks just to avoid buying discs just so they can avoid giving $2 of royalties to starving artists like John Lennon. God I hate these bastards.

On Second Thought

[bugeaterr]

You can not be my Yoko Ono.

Re:So sue to recover the losses

[aproposofwhat]

Lets face it ID's never going to get a fair shake from Darwinoids. Guess it's time to revisit Allan Bloom's, The Closing of the American Mind.

I'll give ID a fair shake - it's complete and utter bullshit, based on a bronze age mythology that has no place in rational discourse.

That enough for you?

If not, I'm perfectly willing to shake it some more, but I can't ever see any truth coming out of it...

Re:So sue to recover the losses

[Gizzmonic]

No wait, one day James Blunt may stop in on a tour and catch you humming "Beautiful" and slap you with a lawsuit for posting a Youtube of you singing it to your girlfriend.

I can guarantee you that will never happen. "Never Gonna Give You Up," sure. I'd rather dry-shave my balls with a dull razor than listen to James Blunt.

Also, I don't bundle the fries anymore, I got promoted to manager. That's why I can post to Slashdot all day without worry. Plus, I get all the Hi-C Orange I can drink without paying a cent! And since the financial crisis is on, more and more people are eating at McDonald's. I don't have to worry about job security. Suck on that one, bro! Anyway, I'm off to smoke dope in the walk-in with my counter guy Jesus. He always has the best shit. Enjoy your layoff!

Re:So sue to recover the losses

[KGIII]

The freedom of religion is child abuse???

Re:Not your decision

[DAldredge]

So should I make my software bug ridden so I can sell support?