RIAA Victim Jammie Thomas Gets a New Lawyer 241
newtley writes "Only days after Brian Toder, her previous legal representative, had decided discretion was the better part of valour, leaving her fend for herself against the RIAA, Jammie Thomas says another lawyer has come forward with an offer of pro bono help. He's K.A.D. Camara from Camara & Sibley in Houston, Texas, says Jammie. And, 'He's the youngest person in history to graduate from Harvard Law school with honors,' she points out. Nor will her retrial be delayed, as was expected. It'll now go forward in June 15, as slated. 'I'm so happy!' Jammie said."
Re:Young lawyer != good lawyer (Score:5, Informative)
From his Wikipedia article:
"A gifted child, he wrote a medical paper on alternative treatments for rheumatoid arthritis at age eleven,[1] which was published in the Hawai'i Journal of Medicine.[2] At sixteen, having skipped high school, Camara earned a Bachelor of Science in computer science from Hawaii Pacific University.[2] He completed the program in two years and was singularly recognized by the university for outstanding academic performance."
Yes, he's just 25 and perhaps could have more experience. But anyhow he seems a pretty smart guy. And note that he is the senior partner in his own law firm.
Re:Non-PC shorthand (Score:1, Informative)
Whoosh!
From the lawyer's website: (Score:5, Informative)
"With Professor Charles Nesson of the Harvard Law School, we are defending Brittany English, a junior and cheerleader at Case Western Reserve University in a prosecution brought by the recording industry under the Copyright Act for allegedly illegal music downloading and sharing. Brittany is counter-suing the Recording Industry Association of America, its members, and the individuals who organized its litigation campaign.
Armed with the threat of $150,000 in statutory damages per illegal download (a $1.5M judgment in a small, 10-song case, where the actual damages are about $10, the price of 10 songs on iTunes), the recording industry has obtained more than $100M in settlements from individuals like Brittany. We are asking the courts to declare that statutory damages like these â" 150,000:1 â" are unconstitutional and that the RIAAâ(TM)s campaign to extract settlements from individuals by the threat of such unconstitutional damages is itself unlawful, enjoin the RIAAâ(TM)s unlawful campaign, and order the RIAA to return the $100M+ that it obtained as a result of its unlawful campaign."
Re:Pro bono doesn't mean out of charity (Score:1, Informative)
No. IIRC, pro bono is a shortened form of pro bono publico, or "For the good of the public". It's a public good for those who are being persecuted in court to have a lawyer, even if they can't afford to pay for a lawyer.
Also, it's generally considered part of being a "professional" to engage in pro bono activities.
Re:Pro bono doesn't mean out of charity (Score:2, Informative)
But if it was pro bono, wouldn't that be $0?
Not quite. The lawyer still incurs costs. His own staff has to be paid (by the lawyer, of course). There's a lot of paperwork = copying costs, filing costs, etc. And he's theoretically losing other business by doing this, so there's lost opportunity cost
Pro bono means $0 to his client. It doesn't mean he incurs no costs himself. And if he can work a way for somebody else to pay these costs, more power to him.
Re:Pro bono doesn't mean out of charity (Score:3, Informative)
No. If you represent a client pro bono, that means that client won't be paying your fees. If you qualify for the various exceptions to the US rule that parties bear the cost of litigation, you can still take advantage of fee-shifting rules.
Re:Non-PC shorthand (Score:3, Informative)
That is an excellent question, considering that more than half of the people I have met who are TRULY African-American were of Caucasian descent. I don't see any particular reason to call a 5th or 6th generation immigrant to America African-American other than to be Politically Correct. I am third generation myself, but I consider myself to be an American and would never ask someone to call me Czechoslovakian-American.
Comment removed (Score:3, Informative)