US Requirement For Software Dev Certification Raises Questions

dcblogs writes "U.S. government contracts often require bidders to have achieved some level of Capability Maturity Model Integration (CMMI). CMMI arose some 25 years ago via the backing of the Department of Defense and the Software Engineering Institute at Carnegie Mellon University. It operated as a federally funded research and development center until a year ago, when CMMI's product responsibility was shifted to a private, profit-making LLC, the CMMI Institute. The Institute is now owned by Carnegie Mellon. Given that the CMMI Institute is now a self-supporting firm, any requirement that companies be certified by it — and spend the money needed to do so — raises a natural question. 'Why is the government mandating that you support a for-profit company?' said Henry Friedman, the CEO of IR Technologies, a company that develops logistics defense related software and uses CMMI. The value of a certification is subject to debate. To what extent does a CMMI certification determine a successful project outcome? CGI Federal, the lead contractor at Healthcare.gov, is a veritable black belt in software development. In 2012, it achieved the highest possible Capability Maturity Model Integration (CMMI) level for development certification, only the 10th company in the U.S. to do so."

Re:So that's what the model is based on

[Anonymous Coward]

As for certifications, like virtually all of them, this one (CMMI) is totally useless in assuring quality.

Yeah, that CMMI stuff is old hat for waterfallers, but don't worry, by 2038, the government will have updated its requirements to mandate that all projects shall be conducted using Agile(tm) methods under the direction of a Certified Scrum Master(tm).

Re:We need to combine CMMI, SOA, Six Sigma, ISO 90

[MichaelSmith]

I worked on that project.