Jon Katz' "Geeks" Goes Hollywood 256
ChrisCrosby was the first
to notice that Hollywood Reporter has a story about our own Jon Katz' soon-to-be-released book "Geeks" being picked up by New Line Cinema for a feature film. Lawrence Bender (producer of Pulp Fiction, Reservoir Dogs, Good Will Hunting and more) and Laurie Bickford are producing. I'm really excited for Jon, and I just wanted to congratulate him: He's been working so hard on this, and the parts of the story that I've read have been really wonderful. And Hemos and I get cameos! Now since Bender has produced all of Quentin Tarantino's films, wouldn't it be fabulous if
he directed this?Update: 01/14 04:09 by H : BTW, the actual book is available for pre-order through ThinkGeek. Check it out.
I cowrote Pulp Fiction -- so trust me when I say.. (Score:1)
He can barely find the power switch to a computer.
You can forget about him even thinking about doing this project for a nanosecond. My guess is that Lawrence is smart enough to know that there's a number of other directors who understand geek culture better. Besides, Quentin is busy doing other things.
-Roger Avary (Academy Award winner for "Pulp Fiction", Director of "Killing Zoe", and daily /. reader)
all I have to say is... (Score:1)
McDougal the Llama
Re:Geeks is already an anime (Score:1)
Brag, brag, brag (Score:1)
Re:It's perfect! (Score:1)
Sucks to your ass-mar.
Wonderful (Score:1)
I can't friggin wait. It'll be full of 'wild 'n' wacky' characters who are growing up in a bright shiny future where their skills are so in demand and they are the great young revolutionaries of the brave new world with exciting paradigms for a new millenium.
hurt maim destroy
Still, compared with the crap we've endured so far from 'hackers' and the like, I'm sure it will be great in comparison.
Re:Congrats With A Question (Score:1)
I especially liked the part where our heros make fake IDs.
After all, that can't be geeks if they aren't using their computers to BREAK THE LAW.
Re:It's perfect! (Score:1)
And for your information, I haven't been an angry adolescent in decades. Or maybe I'm not a geek at all. Hell, when I was a tech at your lovely university's Plasma Physics Labs we programmed micro-sequencers, ran fiber optics and built trackballs from scratch so we could instrument the reactor. Geeky enough? But then we all took off Fridays during the summer, loaded up the gun club with beer and visiting co-eds and got laid once in awhile. As Zappa once said: It's fucking great to be alive. So you'll pardon me if I don't buy into Jon's gloomy navel-gazing vision of the "geek" world he can never really know.
Is that a bad enough attitude for you?
Not like AOL/TW, eh? This is GOOD corporatism. (Score:1)
Re:Visualisation (Score:1)
thanks.
The cast should contain... (Score:1)
I can tell that this movie will be unique, and the total opposite of the Hollywood standard! How exciting! Finally, a movie that will accurately portray geeks, a movie with no stereotypes or dumbed down plots!
Re:Jon's writing style? What about yours? (Score:1)
He said "...his flaws were in his content and his organization."
You replied "Specifically on what basis are his arguments bad? how is the content bad?"
Nobody said there was anything wrong with his arguments. I disagree with many of them, but they're simply different points of view.
As for content, what little content there is, is not "bad", I just think there needs to be much more of it. His Hellmouth bit, though lengthy, was one of the very few Katz articles I almost enjoyed.
The original author of this thread is not alone in his sentiments. Jon would be a much more effective writer if he put a little more emphasis on the facts and did not blither on paragraph after paragraph.
Re:Jon Katz (Score:1)
I second that.
Everybody seems to have a very strong opinion about Katz. I think he's a lousy author. Others love his writing. I haven't a clue as to why, but I can't argue with their dollars.
I'll have to give one of his books a read some time. They simply can't be as bad as his columns. Can they?
Movie? What Movie? (Score:1)
My book: "People who think they're geeks" (Score:1)
I was one of the many that pretty much choked on every article that he wrote and I wanted to get him banned as an author here, but it now seems that Katz and Rob were in cahoots.
This is a really sorry state of affairs for Slashdot. They've effectivly sold out and I have lost tons of respect for them.
Q: Now that Katz has gotten his "inside scoop", can we finially ban him from the system?
--
Steven Webb
System Administrator II - Juneau and TECOM projects
NCAR - Research Applications Program
Re:Writing skills not required (Score:1)
Re:Geez, this seems like typical hollywood fluff (Score:1)
Malachi
Re:It's perfect! (Score:1)
Re:Geez, this seems like typical hollywood fluff (Score:1)
addendum--Katz, Townshend, Beowolf Clusters (Score:1)
With our children at our feet
And the morals that they worship will be gone
And the men who spurred us on
Sit in judgment of all wrong
They decide and a shotgun sings the song
I'll tip my hat to the new constitution
Take a bow for the new revolution
Smile and grin at the change all around
Pick up my guitar and play
Just like yesterday
Then I'll get on my knees and pray
We don't get fooled again
I'll move myself and my family aside
If we happen to be left half alive
Get all my papers and smile at the sky
Tho' I know that the hypnotized never lie
There's nothing in the street
Looks any different to me
And the slogans are replaced by the by
The parting on the left
Is now the parting on the right
And the beards have all grown longer overnight
Make the new boss, same as the old boss
--Pete Townshend
Wafting Another Airball with Jon "Salieri " Katz (Score:1)
A few months ago Jon Katz was the Arch Enemy of the movie industry. If you go back and read his posts you will see that unless the film was made on stolen film stock by hipply dressed college students it was a afront to the intelect of all right thinking citizens.
Well now the table sare turning and Jon Salieri Katz is becoming the center of his own hatred. I cant wait for the article from Katz's MS Word driven creativity to hit slashdot.
"Voices From Hollywood, Geeks FOR $ale"
In it he will interview kids who saw the movie and were harmed by its blatant consumeristic messages. He will ride the author, himself, for being a tool to the white power base that hold down everyone.
Yes, Katz will be profiting not only from the film he will be giving himself more things to pontificate on. He will become the selfperpetuating Crumudgeon.
I cant wait for Katz to hit the silver screen. I m sur it will do well, in fact I pray that it does better than Titanic. I can think of no better reward for Katz then to become the great mass marketed hero of the Geeks. Relegated to live in a world he so depises it will be both his just reward and his self made cell.
So heres to Jon Katz, lets all hope he make sit big soon.
Ahhhh. (Score:1)
You should have put a warning on that.
;)
Re:Visualisation (Score:1)
That being said the best protrayal of copmuters in film that I remember is Real Genius. Besides Hackers of course.
I've read that story before... (Score:1)
They end up in Chicago, livin' la vida malo for a while and finally get hired and then things turn around. Nice heartstring tugging story... really. One of the five archetypal stories (Horatio Alger style).
Anyway, did Katz originally do this in a Wired or Time mag? And besides the obvious draw for wonderful artistic license (not the Artistic License Perl has) with Hollywood dramatization, do we really need another Rags to Riches story (only this time ala Geek)?
This will not go down as one of the top ten geek movies. Those spaces are reserved for classics like Tron, Wargames, Sneakers, The Matrix, and the original trilogy, etc.
Maybe this movie will bolster public opinion that geeks are people too, but I'm going to say that they still want action like the nefarious identity thief in The Net (a movie that has no doubt influenced Katz greatly).
In short, Katz has continued to follow the rules set by many English teachers. And no writer can become great until s/he can understand those rules to a point where s/he can break them.
Congrats (Score:1)
Re:Is there no escape from Katz? (Score:1)
What I want to know is... (Score:1)
:-)
(For the humour impaired, please note the smiley)
--
Hope we have a smash hit (Score:1)
But I hope it dose and it dose well.
Yes I am a Katz fan but byond that I'd like to see OTHER Geek titles make it to the movie screen.
After Y2K the Movie.. based on strips from 1-1-1999 to 1-1-2000.. only instead of the alternet universe ending (that lets the commic continue) a happly ever after ending...
Sluggy Freelance The Movie.. A unique storyline made exclusively for the movie... Live action and lots of specal effects... exposions.. show off that lazer cannon... I wonder who'd play Riff and Torg...
"Let me check my notes"...
My suggestion.. go with all NEW tallent... no stars... hunrgy actors who have proven themselfs in theator for a long time...
User Friendly the movie: No opinion.. I stopped reading the strip but it dose have the cult folowing needed for a big cashin movie.. as long as Illiad retains artistic control it's shure to retain the charm that makes it populare and make it a smash hit.
Keven and Kelly/Heardthiners: The Movie
Animated with Bill Kean in artistic control...
There are HUGE ammounts of strips that would made a sucessful move to the movie screen... a few that wouldn't...
I don't think GPF would make a good movie for example simply becouse it's life is an ongoing commic strip. It's GREAT as a strip. You want to folow the lifes of the carricters...
But for a movie it wouldn't work.. The storys arn't that intresting themselfs.. it's all the ongoing plots.. the stuff that never really resolves itself.. that makes GPF.. That stuff won't translate to a movie becouse the movie ends.. But GPF storys never really do end... The cult of the twisted pair is still around.. the Pookel/Ki storyline is still going.. Fred is still a profesor, Trudys still around... etc... It never ends just stops for a while and lets annother story resume. Dosn't work for a movie format but for a commic strip it's pritty smart.. and addicting...
Sluggy more than the rest sence it's just an ongoing action movie in commic strip form.
I wonder what Goats the movie would look like... ohhh....
Quentin? (Score:1)
How many Geeks "bitch slap" people? How many of them cut off ears? Taratino is a loser and I think would violate anything of vague interest to
Actually, he probably would actually show anything of vague interest to
Uhg, no thanks.
Congrats Jon! (Score:1)
Re:Geez, this seems like typical hollywood fluff (Score:1)
And what, pray tell, is that? bore your audience to tears? Make jokes about klingon puberty? Make 'boob' jokes? Make Troi and Riker amorous again? Waste millions of dollars on a dull movie?
I guess I answered my own question.
Expect it from an odd numbered Trek movie
New Columnist (Score:1)
Re:TROLL??? WTF MODERATOR DUMBFUCKS!!! (Score:1)
"Suble Mind control? why do html buttons say submit?",
Re:Jon Katz (Score:1)
What is it about her face that makes it so treacherous for the tear? I mean, I'd rather read "tears streamed down her face" then what you wrote. If you want to be creative how about: "It couldn't be true, she told herself, feeling the warm saline on her cheeks"
"Suble Mind control? why do html buttons say submit?",
I'm not sure I get it (Score:1)
So, Linus has done more Then Katz. And yet Katz has not done less then Linus? I think there is a hole in your logic there...
"Suble Mind control? why do html buttons say submit?",
Re:topical? (Score:1)
and to emphasize your point: How can your well thought-out comment score a 3 and a post labeled TROLL get a 5?
what's going on here? We will just have to wait to see if the movie sucks or not. Regardless, this IS newsworthy and I would be interested in seeing it.
Re:Geeks is already an anime (Score:1)
----
Dave
Purity Of Essence
Re:You know what Jon Katz is? (Score:1)
Re:Geez, this seems like typical hollywood fluff (Score:1)
I can't say that watching a couple of lonely geeks using usenet and e-mail makes for an intriguing plot, though. Nevertheless, I hope that I'm underestimating it.
-Jennifer
Cameos (Score:2)
Vote for Linus doing the cameo! At least someone can recognize HIM!
Jon Katz (Score:2)
I coulda been a star! (Score:2)
Forget 'movie review'... (Score:2)
*gag*
Seriously, what the hell is going on here? I'm not so concerned with Taco and Hemos et al, they're just running a site and having a great time seeing what trouble they can stir up. I'm shocked (and some would say I shouldn't be) by what Katz will go along with.
Is it in fact true that Jon Katz is exactly the type of corrosive media trendy powerworshipper he purports to be against?
Does he have rationalizations already in place about how he's not really leveraging his new-media connections to gain special privileges with the very same corporate media dinosaur he claims to hate and fear?
Which would he choose, to have his film carefully sterilized to be suitable for general audiences, or to have 'his people' sneak children into theaters to see his film?
*sigh* really, this whole business is disgusting. I would have no gripe with Katz doing this if he was sincere in his desire to align himself with the existing power structures of media that so many of us have to fight against. But he is not- something is wrong with his mind, that he can't see the phenomenal hypocrisy of his actions and desires.
I'm looking at Jon's reaction to the AOL/Time Warner merger, and it's bitterly funny how the whole first paragraph is bitching not about social issues, or the media implications, but the gripes of a _disgruntled_ _consumer_. And then, the relevance... "Is individualism, free expression, diverse opinion advanced when the information economy breaks down into two or three "old and new" media conglomerates that control virtually all of the archived news and entertainment information online, and increasingly, the means to deliver it?"
Well, Jon, never mind that, eh? Which one of the media conglomerates do you like the best for your movie? It's true that taking an option doesn't mean squat in the biz, and the movie may never be made- but as we watch you dance with big media, first Amazon now the film industry in your ever-broadening search for an audience that will accept you as their guru, it's impossible to overlook some things now.
If your dream continues, you may continue to mouth the same words you've been reciting for years, and you may continue to make a pretense of outrage against corporatism and big media: but the truth will be this: You are not only supporting corporatism and big media... let me spell it out.
You. Are. In. Their. Pay.
Traitor.
I wonder how they'll modify it... (Score:2)
Regardless, congradulations, Jon. Well done, sir.
--
Re:Do you know what the funny thing about /. is? (Score:2)
"Big KahunaLinux? That's that new Hawaiian RedHat variant, isn't it?"
I now declare the Pulp Fiction parodies over...
(if only t'were true)
--
I've read it... (Score:2)
----------------
"Great spirits have always encountered violent opposition from mediocre minds." - Albert Einstein
This is an interesting example of "media synergy" (Score:2)
Katz writes for Slashdot. He also writes books. Slashdot features Katz's book as coming out RSN. This is good. And there may be a movie, with bit parts for the fellows who run Slashdot. Also neat.
Tacked on at the end of the article is an opportunity to pre-order the book from ThinkGeek, a cool online store that just happens to be owned by Slashdot's parent - Andover.net. So Andover, Slashdot, and ThinkGeek have turned an interesting story into a revenue opportunity. This is the future, folks - get used to it.
There's nothing wrong with cross-selling within your properties, but you'll see a lot more of it from companies a lot less trustworthy than Andover. Be prepared.
That said, congratulations, Jon. I'll be one of the first to buy a copy when it comes out!
- -Josh Turiel
Re:My new book (Score:2)
"Terse: The gratuitously sententious explication of an undeniable superfluity of informational concepts best reserved for the interior surface of the pressed wood pulp integument hereof."
Re:Do you know what the funny thing about /. is? (Score:2)
but there they're little different.
Example? (8
I'm sorry. What I meant to say was 'please excuse me.'
what came out of my mouth was 'Move or I'll kill you!'
Re:Congrats With A Question (Score:2)
Here's a US Census report [census.gov] showing that Idaho had the third largest percentage growth in population from 1990 through 1999. The news outlets of the Treasure Valley (which includes Boise, Meridian, Nampa, and Caldwell) continually report surveys and studies showing that the area is growing at a phenomenal rate -- but I hadn't found any links to those yet.
Don't forget, the low population density, clean air, wide open spaces, and outdoor recreation make this (and other Western states besides California) seem like paradise to disenchanted high-tech workers who have money and jobs to offer.
--
Re:Resevoir Geeks? Pulp Slashdot? (Score:2)
Re:Quentin? (Score:2)
LK
Re:Resevoir Geeks? Pulp Slashdot? (Score:2)
Reminds me of Pulp Simpsons [jinxworld.com]. Especially the picture of Homer... "Hmmm, big KARMA burger!!" Oooh! That's FUNNY!! Ahh...
Visualisation (Score:2)
a movie about real geeks who 'find a community on the internet'.
While that could be an interesting story, I wonder how they will be able to visualise it. Are we going to have to look at two geeks surfing and chatting for 90 minutes?
Greetings,
Ivo
Microserfs (Score:2)
But then again, neither did the story of Nick Leeson and it was made into a film.
Re:Yes so? (Score:2)
I didn't say that. I said "Seems to enjoy".
Music and films are all based on trends.
The trends are followed to make the maximum money.
It was just a coincidence that there's about 20girl bands all being formed at the same time.
It was just a coincidence that last summer (UK)
nearly every movie was a teen highschool romantic comedy (She's al that, 10TIHAY, Never been kissed, American Pie, Election)
I also never implied it would continue along the same lines, everyone gets bored, the trends change, the movie/music moguls follow where they are lead.
And most people do buy into the hype.
QV: The Phantom Menace, Jurassic Park, The Matrix, The Spice Girls, and many many more.
Re:Microserfs (Score:2)
I don't really see Matthew Perry as the nerdy M$ programmer trying to find himself type. Ick
Re:Geez, this seems like typical hollywood fluff (Score:2)
If the public seems to enjoy one prequel released 22 years after the original, then they want every movie to have a prequel released 22years afterwards. If they like "scary" movies that have no visible scary entity, they want all movies to have no visible scary entity.
If we liked one girl band, then we'll love it when there's 1000 of them
It's all about money, and trends.
Unfortunatly.
Good news for Katzdot (Score:2)
Scriptwriting (Score:2)
First, congrats, Jon!
Now on for the real stuff. I'm sure Katz has sent more than a few people on /. an advanced readers editition. If you've read it, I'm really wondering how they are going to handle the story as Katz himself becomes intertwined with the story. The book isn't written as a third-person narrative; rather, Katz is there. Are we going to see someone playing Katz or are we going to see a rewrite to third-person?
----
Re:Good news for Katzdot (Score:2)
--
Geez, this seems like typical hollywood fluff (Score:2)
Visualisation of a different sort... (Score:2)
Theoretical situation:
Enter Jon Katz
"Hi, I'm Jon Katz, here to introduce my movie. I'll start by briefly discussing how technology affects the many people in society. Why, just recently I was
Eye's heavy. Can't think.. Sleepy.. fading..
The geeks fall asleep. The marketters in the audience are enthralled.
72 minutes later...
"So that's how I got to work with the cool Slashdot guys. Here's the movie."
Jon Katz steps to the side to watch the responce.
A familiar [thesync.com] theme song starts up.
Geeks in audience start to groggily wake.
"WHAT THE HELL!? This is just Geeks In Space playing! Wait, what's that on the screen..."
On the screen, an image that is sometimes a mandelbrot set and sometimes a julia set is jiggling through a tunnel like image. It is not anti-aliased, and looks very pixelated.
"Hey, I recognize that, that's a sonqiue visualisation plugin. That bastard is making money from boring us to tears, and the slashdot crew's own music! And using a pathetic Windows MP3 player with no anti-aliasing.. LET'S GET 'IM!"
The geeks swarm over Jon, leaving nothing behind but a laptop with a pre-release of Windows 2000 Professional on it. On their way out the theatre, they also start mobbing the marketters in the audience, and incite a few riots around Radio Shack.
[fin]
Yeah, so if this movie is just Jon/Mp3 visualisation, we'll be on you like stink on a monkey. We at Echsuh (the Elite Cabal of High School and University Hackers) are not to be toyed with!
(/joke)
At-choo
---
Congrats With A Question (Score:2)
Re:Jon Katz (Score:2)
*lol*
amusing (Score:2)
ok??
thanks,
and have a nice day
Yes so? (Score:2)
If the public seems to enjoy one prequel released 22 years after the original, then they want every movie to have a prequel released 22years afterwards. If they like "scary" movies that
have no visible scary entity, they want all movies to have no visible scary entity.
If we liked one girl band, then we'll love it when there's 1000 of them
No I don't think *everyone* wanted it. I thought it was a stupid move just for fanatics of the movies in the 70s but I guess that's just me. The future of the world isn't going to change at all it's just what one person decides to do with their time. Why do people always see conspiracies in areas that don't really have the brains to create them? Movie producers and people in the music industry are the last people I would actually credit with anything significant.
It's all about money, and trends.
Maybe but not everyone buys into hype and such. Just wait until all of the people who are living now get a little older and start to throw their weight around a little more. I very much doubt that anything you see will continue.
Re:Geez, this seems like typical hollywood fluff (Score:2)
Movies should take advantage of all the actual technology that we have nowadays. Failing that we should have movies that actualy have acturate depictions or proper decision making and perhaps more utilitarian concepts. Take a look at the last ST movie for an example of what you should *not* do. People are not and should not be portrayed as fools. Making them appear to be foolish makes the entire plot less believable.
Generally you should not let a group of individuals who have little to gain affect the general betterment of the group. In real life such sacrifices do not get anywhere because they are pointless except for allegorical purposes for future generations nothing more.
Re:Geez, this seems like typical hollywood fluff (Score:2)
who meet over the internet. That's _really_ vague. The only movie that I remember that this even remotely resembles is "You've Got Mail", which better reminds me of "Sleepless
in Seattle".
Well that's really not that interesting at all. Geeks by their very nature are not lonely but are a social amalgm between computers and humans. I for one if I had a good enough computer would never leave my house only for the most basic of necessities.
I can't say that watching a couple of lonely geeks using usenet and e-mail makes for an intriguing plot, though. Nevertheless, I hope that I'm underestimating it.
Not only that I can't really see a logical group (which I assume most of slashdot is) would actual type of thing. Logic is the norm of the universe so says chaso theory.
Re:Jon Katz (Score:2)
prime example for what I'm saying. Although Jon Katz seems to be well educated, his written skills leave something to be desired. As many have pointed out his writing style is
trite and not creative. One get's the feeling that he does this to boost his already inflated public image, and in so doing keeping the dollar signs rolling in. It's hard to blame him
though, money can make people do strange things. Best of luck your endevours Mr. Katz as I'm sure you know exactly what it is you're doing.
Why all this emphasis on what we term "creativity"? There eventually comes a time when all literary forms become trite and obsolete and boring. The only thing left after about 1950 that was absolutely really new and groundbreaking in terms of literature was perhaps random groups of text that meant nothing; and even that can be done in emacs with the dissociated press program. Just because this guy is probably as old as my father and that he has a very traditional concept of what the future is dosn't mean that his opioion is crap. I mean if you look at things like The Wizard of Oz (basically a kind of projection about what the future city would look like) you can see this in action. How about old crappy science fiction things. There is no chance that people will ever do anything in such a tacky manner.
Re:Jon Katz (Score:2)
by definition, trite. An example of a cliche is: "Tears streamed down her face". You could rephrase this to make it non-cliche: "Tears spasmed over the boundaries of her eye lids,
cascading down the trecherous terrain of her face". Do you consider the second one more creative? I do.
Well the mental image of the first seems to be a tender one perhaps evoking sympathy more. The second is indeed creative but it just seems more to concentrate on the physical features of the person in question. Perhaps the second would be good perhaps if the person in question had just fallen down a hill or perhaps we are attempting to impart some sense of the tramatic nature of the event that the tears are being produced for. Not all cliches are bad. If you read a great deal of romance novels I am sure that the first would be perhaps a cliche. But what if you are exposed to say classical literature? How can you effectively judge something to be a cliche? What happens if we run out of effective methods of describing the act of crying? Well in English we have at least one method in creating a continum of words in severity or emotional impact. Consider the act of crying.
We have:
1. watering eyes -- perhaps slight crying
2. crying -- the actual act itself without too much
3. sobbing -- more intense than crying and involves more emphasis.
4. bawling -- more "earthy" generally used to refer to "simple" people or situations less human
Those 4 examples are the only ones that I can come up without stepping too deeply into the metaphor but as you can see there are ways to do it but even the cliche is still necessary to give that sensation.
Re:Congrats With A Question (Score:2)
plant, and rusty old pickups with shotguns and loud radios tuned to the country music station, and he bought it. I don't know anyone in the area who read the Wired article and
took it seriously. GASP! It's hard to imagine a mind as sharp as Katz being "snowballed" he's the smartest guy ever ever EVER!!! His writing can ONLY be compared to the bible.
I mean, both have such strong grasps on LOGIC AND REALITY!
Like people in the modern age reality is seen in the eye of the beholder. Maybe it *was* reality in the community that those kids lived in. Perhaps they did live in the sticks and it was true. Unless you live there and could relate the actual physical/social/political conditions of the area you cannot say he was snowballed.
Re:Jon Katz (Score:2)
Is there anything better? Could andover afford these people? Come on this isn't Time or US News and World Report or even Variety this is an internet site and because of this and it's theme "News for Nerds: Stuff that Matters" we have a rather low selection because this isn't a trade magazine or anything like that. I think the more information that is posted to slashdot the better in terms of idea flow. The flow ideas is what created the open source movement and it is the only thing preventing it's demise. I would really like to see someone (from slashdot that is) produce an essay on the same topic as John Katz and have people judge if it is better. I don't think it's as easy as it looks.
PS. (And no random perl scripts that use syntastic english grammer parsers to recreate not so funny combinations of "essays" are only funny for about 2.567334 minutes exactly).
Re:Congrats With A Question (Score:2)
worth watching as something other than a parody.
How did Idaho get that rating in the first place? What's the source I wold be quite suprised at this considering the low population density of most of the state and your earlier descriptions of the place being possibly home to large quantities of hillbillies.
Re:Jon's writing style? What about yours? (Score:2)
content and his organization. I'll thank you for thinking before you're cynical next time.
Specifically on what basis are the arguments bad? How is the content bad? Are there any ways to actually conclusively proving him wrong? Has anything he said actually been documented as wrong. People such as I need hard and conclusive evidence that what is being said is actually the truth. The only thing that I see is that he tries to make predictions on events and social situations that are not easily predictable in most ways. Like some of the sci-fi people in years past. I remember reading a book back in elementary school which said that by the 1990s we would have moon bases and be on our way to mars. Well have any of these things happened? No because people would rather live out their pathetic lives on good ol' planet earth and not actually explore space. Let me give you a little prediction of mine. ST TNG level of technology will be about 30,000 years in the future there is no way that we will have it in 2390 or so.
I'm Confused! (Score:2)
Is the movie supposed to be a documentary or something? Somehow I was under the impression that Katz's book 'Geeks' was not a work of fiction -- or at least not fiction in the same sense that 'Microserfs' was.
So which is it? Is 'Geeks' a novel with some real-world characters or is it a 'non-fictional' 'real-life' depiction of us geeks at work and play? And what does either possibility say about the movie deal? Someone help me out here!
Jack
Re:???Maybe Kevin Smith??? (Score:2)
Methinks KS will be tied up with Clerks, the Animated Series, and then Clerks 2 for some time to come...
For more Kevin Smith info try here [viewaskew.com]
Deleting JonKatz HowTo (Score:2)
_________________________
Re:if the movie ..)(Bully Thread begins) (Score:2)
"extrapolation": you are old, bitter, and unhappy with your life, and wish the days of you whupping someone for their lunch money would come back so you could have some value again?
Strangely enough, the jocks that used to do that same thing to me in school have mostly passed from this world into whatever lies after, due to their inability to grasp that the real world is NOT high school, and people OUTSIDE of school are ALLOWED to carry weapons, not prohibited from doing it, for the very reason they get used for. Stopping obnoxious bully's and thiefs for once and for all.
*grin*
Geeks with guns.. we're everywhere, we're everywhere.
Maeryk
Do you know what the funny thing about /. is? (Score:2)
Regards,
j.
P.S. Now describe to me what JonKatz looks like!
Re:Visualisation (Score:2)
I gag every time I see that in movies.
Remeber Jurassic Park: "I know this. This is Unix."
Yup their "emergency" system is a 3D interface they have to navigate to shut down the darn thing. That is really smart.
Corrinne Yu
3D Game Engine Programmer
moderation (Score:2)
Corrinne Yu
3D Game Engine Programmer
Mandatory Reality Check (Score:2)
Linux Pulp Fiction (Score:3)
What, OS Royale?
Actually, I think they still call it Linux.
Re:Congrats With A Question (Score:3)
The book is about those two kids Katz interviewed, huh? I grew up in Idaho, 20 miles from where those kids did. It's not exactly Silicon Valley, but there are a whole lot of technology companies there right now, like HP and Micron and Extended Systems and dozens of smaller firms, as well as the headquarters of other companies like Albertsons and Boise Cascade.
Katz got snowed by those kids, that's what happened. They fed him some line about how their lives sucked because the only things in Idaho are potato farms, that sugar beet plant, and rusty old pickups with shotguns and loud radios tuned to the country music station, and he bought it. I don't know anyone in the area who read the Wired article and took it seriously.
Now if the subtitle of the movie is "How a gullible journalist got taken in by a couple of lazy kids who can't find jobs in the 3rd fastest growing area in the U.S.", maybe it'll be worth watching as something other than a parody.
--
Samuel L. Jackson as a geek (Score:3)
________________________________
This is bad for the 'net, the world is ending. (Score:3)
When a major multi-national corporation distributes a book it crushes all competition and it is the end of print media.
This is compounded by the backing of a media powerhouse like a studio. First they make one movie and before you know it, they are making all of the movies and they control the world.
This move is a corruption of the OpenSource spirit and the sky is falling and the world is ending.
Congratulations on your new deal!
Re:???Maybe Kevin Smith??? (Score:3)
(shudder)
How about Slashdot the Sitcom? (Score:3)
There are lots of easy plot ideas. The guys meet one of the "first post" guys, who turns out to be some famous celebrity (preferably an attractive female one). Hemo's hamster gets killed by crawling into a computer, the guys have an adventure replacing it, etc.
Eventually, however, they'd end up transferring Lt. Worf to the geek compound to boost ratings.
It would turn out to be a boon to the writers, who finally get the chance to eliminate Jon Katz' character, despite his immense popularity as a result of being played by michael richards. ("Katz!")
Worf : Katz! In writing these articles you insult my Klingon Ancestors! [Worf cleaves Katz]
topical? (Score:3)
As for this news, I think it is GOOD news.. I find myself in agreeance with Jon's views in a lot of cases, but the convoluted way he gets to it sometimes leads me to wish he had an editor. However, remember, Einstein could barely write legibly, let alone grammatically correctly. So what? do we ignore everything he had to say because the man wrote badly? No, we hail him as a genius and work around his learning disorders.
I personally WELCOME a geek movie from Jon.. at least he has read enough comments FROM the geek community to get a feel for it, even if he doesnt share that communitys viewpoints in the majority (or the vocal minority, im still not sure which applies here). But, im sure the film will turn (if made) out better than Hackers, or any of the other stupid films that have attempted to paint uber-geeks as gutter punks with antique hardware whose life revolves around boy meets girl and hacking el evil corporation.
I realy hope that this film gets made, and I hope Jon holds some sway over the final outcome. (if he is true to his beliefs, I think he would anyway, or would block the production of it, much as Gibson did with all the characters out of Neuromancer cept Johnny).
Anyway.. Kudos to you Katz, good luck, and have fun!
cameo, phbbbt! (Score:3)
Hey, I'll stunt-double for CmdrTaco. You never know when you might be swapping out some RAM and get a nasty shock. Wouldn't want that to happen on film. The girl geeks would definitely not dig it. OTOH, stunt men are chick magnets, as anyone knows.... ;)
It would be perfect! We even share the same initials! Really, dude, you gotta have me as your stunt man.
CT
Ya know... (Score:4)
Back when Katz was young and hadn't smoked too much dope, there was a subculture called 'hippies'. There were a certain amount of hippies that were perfectly sincere, and quite a lot of plastic imitations cruising over to the Haight on the weekends. (No, I wasn't one of the latter, I was about 3 months old at the time).
Eventually hippieness became a media explosion, infighting set in, and now hippie is largely an epithet, a term of abuse or embarrassment and something to be repudiated.
Thanks to Jon Katz, I can foresee a time when geek becomes equally an embarrassment. Where hippie became synonymous with an airheaded spacecase, geek will become synonymous with a sociopathic, daylight-fearing danger to society.
And maybe that's good, because then we can get back to being people for a change. :P
Unfortunate (Score:4)
I find it really unfortunate that Lawrence Bender and his people are doing this, because it means it probably won't completely suck, and it deserves to. I must say I'm surprised, one thing about Bender's movies is that they've always been in some way new and original, and not typical Hollywood rehashing of the same themes we've already seen before. Not JonKatz. JonKatz is pro-Geek, anti-Censorship, anti-American/Establishment, anti-Conservative, anti-Religious, pro-Conspiracy-Theory, pro-Porn, pro-mp3, pro-linux, anti-MS. Wow, what an amazing set of original creeds! (or not) I can't wait to see all the twists and surprises in this movie!
JonKatz loves to play off the contradiction which is the popularity of 'alternative' culture. Geeks are alternative, so JonKatz has to write good things about them. Same with linux and mp3s and everything else. The y2k bug became too mainstream, so JonKatz had to say that it was a stupid overhyped thing which didn't matter.
The problem is that he doesn't actually think for himself too often. If you remember any of the old articles he posted (the ones where he stilled talked about computers, and used the word 'geek' 3 times per paragraph), it was obvious he had no idea what he was talking about or being a geek was. Of course sometimes he got the main point correct, but only incidentally, and without a lot of depth of discussion behind it.
The best part of JonKatz's articles has always been the user comments. I don't think we'll get that in the movie.
Besides, JonKatz once called Contact a failure, how can he ever be involved with the making of a good movie?
I can't wait to see how many times he uses the word 'geek' and uses microsoft-html in his movie.
It's perfect! (Score:4)
"And Hemos and I get cameos!"
This explains why Katz is still around, I guess.
(goodbye 70+ karma...)
---
Resevoir Geeks? Pulp Slashdot? (Score:4)
Are you SURE that Tarantino directing would be such a good idea?
Mind you, the thought of CmdrTaco in a Gimp mask is kinda appropriate...
???Maybe Kevin Smith??? (Score:4)
It would be great if there were cameos (or parts) for Silent Bob (KS) and Jay (I'll never get enough of those two.
Re:It's perfect! (Score:4)
Your comments about Katz are completely out of line. He has done more to help geeks and the "geek cause" than anyone I've ever heard of. Read his latest book when it comes out (_Geeks_). Even if you disagree with his view of tech culture, you should at least be able to admit that he deserves more respect than you've shown him in these posts.
In addition, CmdrTaco and Hemos also deserve more respect. Your 70+ karma is nothing compared to what they've done. They help run
much to be proud of. I've even looked at your high moderation posts and found that they are almost uniformly examples of the problems with the moderation system.
I don't know CmdrTaco and Hemos, but I have a passing acquaintance with Katz, and I do not find him to be a pseudo- anything. He is an intelligent author and a worthwhile conversationalist. If you don't see that from his
posts, you should at least let what respect you have for the
Now I've had another glimpse into the dark side of the geek. All I see is a bunch of angry adolescents who improperly focus their pain on aggression against those who are slightly different then they are. It is sickening and
fascinating that the same childish impulse to hurt and exclude others that in the vast majority of cases forced geeks to become geeks shows up again in the geek community it created.
I think you'll find killing Piggy doesn't make people love you. Of course this time Piggy has the high ground. It speaks well for him that he doesn't choose to take advantage of it.
Re:Short List (Score:5)
The opening titles would begin with a bunch of really lame dorks who appear on screen for no reason and shout "FIRST CAMEO DUDE!!!"
The film would be periodically interrupted with hysterically funny haiku, apropos of what was happening in the plot at that moment.
Of course, there would have to be a retelling of the legend of Pygmalion, starring MEEPT as Pygmalion and Natalie Portman as Galatea.
The closing credits could have somebody reading the Slashdot Address, the M&M-breeding article, or a Generic Flame--or perhaps all three at once, since no one will actually be paying attention.
Maybe the dialogue in the film itself could be moderated to different volume levels.
RE: Samuel L. Jackson as a geek. (Score:5)
"Reach in that bag and give back that Palm Pilot."
"The one that says 'Bad Motherfucker' on the case."
Ving Rhames as a geek
"We're going to get a couple of Jolt fiending programmers and get object oriented on his ass."
Tarantino...
"Where do you see 'dead vaio storage' ?"
I gotta get back to work, I can keep this up all day...
LK
Keep your pants on, this doesn't mean we'll see it (Score:5)
Remember DOOM was optioned for a movie at least 3, 4 years ago. the options have been bought and sold around Hollywood, and we're still not even close to seeing a feature film.