Gifted Children Find Heavy Metal Comforting 585
An anonymous reader writes "The Daily Telegraph is reporting that intelligent teenagers often listen to heavy metal music to cope with the pressures associated with being talented, according to research.
Researchers found that, far from being a sign of delinquency and poor academic ability, many adolescent "metalheads" are extremely bright and often use the music to help them deal with the stresses and strains of being gifted social outsiders."
Re:Punk (Score:5, Insightful)
Really? Isn't most head bangin' heavy metal disseminated by the recording industry?
Yep. (Score:5, Insightful)
Hard rock, progressive rock, and heavy metal all usually talk about social and political issues in a manner that is both musical and lyrical, and it's a lot easier to dig into and associate with than the lamenting dorks that populate alternative and indie rock nowadays.
Also.. (Score:2, Insightful)
Rock, R&B, and Pop are all better than Heavy M (Score:2, Insightful)
So over six times as many gifted kids use rock music to cope with being S.M.R.T., and the heavy metal kids are more likely to have low self-esteem and difficulties with relationships.
How the hell is this good news for teen metal fans or parents of same? If your kid likes metal, they might be a genius, but a maladjusted one with little confidence. Alternately, if your kids likes rock, they are 6.6 times more likely to be a genius.
The summary is a true masterwork of spin and the Telegraph editors should be spanked for skewing the article so blatantly.
Also, I had no idea percent was two words in British English...
Re:So if heavy metal listeners are so smart.... (Score:3, Insightful)
Evidently Metallica have been playing for so long that it's some time since they actually listened to their own music (as can be evidenced by a quick play of, say, S&M)
possible explanation (Score:4, Insightful)
Or the simpler explanation... (Score:5, Insightful)
Resist the Crowd Mentality (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:Punk (Score:4, Insightful)
As for heavy metal being related to gifted children.. Hmm no. Because music is a personal thing and people will tend to enjoy what they are exposed to at a young age and leaves a lasting impression. So right now rap, girl bands, heavy metal (the pointless screaming type) and punk would be popular with children (0-12ish) in most cases. Where as back in my day (born 86) we had more dance music and retro stuff from the 70s and 80s still hanging around. Which would be very similar to my taste in music now.
Plus children are fickle, if we gave them the entire catalog of music they would have a new favourite band/style every other day.
Re:"head bangers" (Score:2, Insightful)
I found another article by him, which shows he has been watching (and knows) this same cultural group of people for some time and this article also explains (more than a few) rock chicks I've met over the years.
http://www.ucl.ac.uk/news/news-articles/0701/0701
Marilyn Manson (Score:5, Insightful)
That's because it's not cool anymore. (Score:4, Insightful)
I think that this article is more like "nerdy kids listen to music that isn't cool."
Re:Gifted children aren't a monoculture. (Score:1, Insightful)
Rap on the other hand... (Score:2, Insightful)
Granted, there has been some slightly more cerebral rap since the eighties, but for the most part rap is self aggrandizing crap. "I'm, so cool, the hos love me so, I kill you whitey..." etc, etc.
Labels are bad news (Score:5, Insightful)
Most kids are gifted one way or another, some academically, some otherwise. Just most kids don't experience the environments that bring the best out of the kids.
Re:It's so true. (Score:3, Insightful)
Motorhead *is* classical music.
Seriously... metal of all types is a natural offshoot of western classical music as punk is of folk music.
Compare Jake Thackray and the Sex Pistols. They even sing about the same things. Almost.
My experience was just the opposite... (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:Or the simpler explanation... (Score:3, Insightful)
Basically, we all had remarkably different tastes and I would really be very surprised if there was any significant and meaningful correlation between taste in music and intelligence.
Re:Punk (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:Punk (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:Heavy metal as a detox? (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:Punk (Score:5, Insightful)
Linking music tastes and intelligence is really, really, wrong. What kind of music you like depends on so many factors, mostly environmental but... anyway.
Let's take a look at the article: Translation: Some psychologist asked some kids what kind of music they liked and they answered heavy metal. Oh and they also weren't complete idiots.
Since the sample was so big (almost 20 people!), obviously all "gifted" (definition?) children must listen to heavy metal. But since most of heavy metal is crap, he couldn't help but wonder why did these kids listen to this kind of crap. Ah! That makes sense, because smart people worry about society and stuff. The psychologist thought that his findings were so great he had to share them with the rest of the world, but he needed some statistics, so on his way home he asked some more kids about what kind of music they liked so he can make useless statistics that help make a research look all that much more professional: Okay so he found that from a group of supposedly smart kids (although I'm not sure that academia equals intelligence), SIX percent really likes bands like tool, slipknot and system of a down (which are very popular bands anyway) and about one third said "tool? they're cool, I used to listen to aenima a lot". Did that miniscule percentage surprise him that much that he had to go and tell the world?
Academic ability? (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:My experience was just the opposite... (Score:5, Insightful)
In my experience kids who use labels to manipulate their parents only do so because they are allowed to, the parents tend to be push-overs.
Re:Yep. (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:So if heavy metal listeners are so smart.... (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:Punk (Score:5, Insightful)
I think this may reflect you reading your own political position into punk/geek culture more than anything else. Geeks and Punks share a kind of anti-authoritarianism that doesn't map well into the (mostly bullshit) left-right political spectrum. Geek libertarianism and Punk DIY-anarchism fit parts of the left and parts of the right. Matching the left, they care about solidarity, anti-corporatism, and socio-cultural liberty. Matching the right, they care about negative freedoms (small, limited government as opposed to the nanny state) and "rugged individualism."
Re:Punk (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:RTFA, baby. (Score:4, Insightful)
Aw cmon, now. That's just like the R&B kids calling heavy metal "crazy devil music". There is some good R&B out there just like there's some good metal. What you said is just as ridiculous as the guy above who said punk was dead.
Re:It's so true. (Score:3, Insightful)
Some don't even try to hide it, for example "Classical Metal" like some of the works of Yngwie Malmsteen...
Re:Labels are bad news (Score:5, Insightful)
Oh please! Can't we get an article about gifted children or aspergers or something like that without someone making a stupid lowest common denominator post like this? Yes. I'm sure the things you have stated in your post happen. It is stupid, it shouldn't happen, but it does. The problem is, it has nothing to do with the article. Do you really find it so hard to believe that there are smart kids who find life stressful because they don't fit in, so they listen to heavy metal music?
There really are people out there who think that kids who are called "gifted" are just spoiled brats, and that people with asperger syndrome are just shy and need to get out more. Simply because some spoiled brats get called gifted or because some nerds falsely claim to have aspergers. Posts like yours just add to that, without bringing anything useful. Just the same obvious "damn I'm such a rebel for pointing this out" obvious boilerplate post.
P.S. The title for your post is "Labels are bad news". Believe it or not, all words are labels. Do you think words are bad? Just because using a single word like "gifted" doesn't perfectly describe something as complex as a person? This whole anti-label thing is idiotic. Just speak in complete sentences and you fill find that words/labels work to convey a point of view, even if they don't carry enough meaning one at a time. Imagine that!
Re:Punk (Score:3, Insightful)
Never. The right and the left are both in favor of big government since they're defined by how they like to use that big government against the people.
The left to enforce their ideas of equality and the right to enforce their ideas of inequality or elitism.
The right hasn't changed since the term came into being when the nobility and the Church sat on the right hand side of the aisle in the French assembly and the representatives of the commoners sat on the left.
What's changed is, in America, the left subverted the term Liberal and the right attacked it outright in order to destroy the idea. That's why hardly anybody in this country can even discuss politics without sounding ignorant since they don't even have the vocabulary for it. They think Republican == right and Democrat == left even when they both support policies on either side. What neither of them support is Liberalism, i.e. the philosophy of individual liberty. In fact, there is nothing they fear and despise more.
Re:RTFA, baby. (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:Here we go again... (Score:2, Insightful)
Ah, but without taking that assumption, most statistical data is meaningless, which could put a whole bunch of "researchers" out of work. "Correlation, causation, they're both big words that start with 'C', they're practically the same, let's just assume they are!"
Re:Punk (Score:3, Insightful)
Actually I'm ashamed I go back here and read Slashdot, but I'm addicted to posting comments clarifying the BS posing as articles. It's a trap. For reals.
Re:Punk (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Not quite heavy metal... (Score:3, Insightful)
Another factor that may cause "gifted" individuals to listen to metal is the complexity and technicality. If you break down metal music, you'll find that it's much more "musical" then any modern bands. Bands such as Slayer, Amon Amarth, Nile, Testament, and Kreator play with such precision and technical perfection. Anyone who has taken music theory can easily see that this genre is superior to most modern pop. While the growling lyrics may be intimidating to many, there are metal bands out there that combine the brutal and technical musical style with epic and melodic vocals. Examples would be Falconer, Ensiferium, Sonata Arctica, and Iced Earth. In fact, the lead singer of Falconer is actually a Shakespearian actor and has played the leading role in many Broadway style musicals.
Of course, unless you consider the nu-metal(pop metal) bands like Slipknot that crank as much overdrive as they can into the amp and bang incoherently on their guitars. They give "metal" a band wrap.
Re:Punk (Score:3, Insightful)
The Ramones
The Clash
Sex Pistols
The Stooges
All released on major labels (therefore RIAA)....lots and lots more, but I'm lazy. The whole "sell out" label that holier than thou types throw around with abandon really annoys the piss out of me.
Re:My experience was just the opposite... (Score:3, Insightful)
However, the proportion of slashdotters who qualify as "highly gifted" or better in the precise medical sense (ie having an IQ of at least 145) is still very small.