Canada Quietly Offering Sanctuary To Data From the US

davecb writes "The Toronto Star's lead article today is Canada courting U.S. web giants in wake of NSA spy scandal, an effort to convince them their customer data is safer here. This follows related moves like Cisco moving R&D to Toronto. Industry Canada will neither confirm nor deny that European and U.S. companies are negotiating to move confidential data away from the U.S. This critically depends on recent blocking legislation to get around cases like U.S. v. Bank of Nova Scotia, where U.S. courts 'extradited' Canadian bank records to the U.S. Contrary to Canadian law, you understand ..."

Implying Canada isn't an accomplice

[Anonymous Coward]

They've been doing intelligence cooperation with the US for ages, why would they be any more trustworthy?

Meaningless

[dreamchaser]

This is completely meaningless as long as any data has to traverse any network in the US. For that matter, I highly doubt that Canada or any other US ally won't actually cooperate with the NSA. This is nothing but a marketing move on Canada's part.

Re:Meaningless

[Charliemopps]

Its all about the perception of their customers. US territory is tainted in the eyes of the world now.

Re:You Know They'll Roll Over!

[Vanderhoth]

Yeah, I'm Canadian. Canada has a pretty good "sharing" relationship with the US. It's a safe bet that if data is stored here we're pretty much just going to hand it to any US government org. that asks for it. I'd be willing to bet this is a scheme cooked up by the NSA because they know Canada will just roll over and hand the info back to them so they can just continue on business as usual. We're not really the confrontational types up here.

Welcome to your data

[alexhs]

American citizens, come and host your data on canadian soil !
Therefore, it will technically be foreign data.
Therefore, the NSA will be able to spy on it without trespassing any law regulating spying on its own citizens.
Thanks for your cooperation.

Re:You Know They'll Roll Over!

[MouseR]

I think it would be worse for US to store their data in Canada because at that point, NSA is just spying on another country rather than in their own turf. Something that is in high scrutiny at the moment.

Comment removed

[account_deleted]

Comment removed based on user account deletion

Re:You Know They'll Roll Over!

[wonkey_monkey]

Thank you

Thank you kindly.

Re:You Know They'll Roll Over!

[Registered Coward v2]

I think it would be worse for US to store their data in Canada because at that point, NSA is just spying on another country rather than in their own turf. Something that is in high scrutiny at the moment.

Excellant point. Data stored abroad would not necessarily be afforded the same legal protections as data stored in the US. Even given the recent revelations companies should take that into consideration as well.

Re:Implying Canada isn't an accomplice

[scamper_22]

As a Canadian, I always find our ability to blame everything on America quite interesting.

Anything that is not some liberal utopian ideal is BECAUSE AMERICA.

We talk about drug laws in Canada... and it's those damn Americans who force us into the war on drugs. Of course Canada's history isn't full of old conservative white folks who feared Chinese workers and their opium.

We talk about sexuality and its the damn American influence that prevents us from being a nudist paradise.
We don't have any history of conservatism or banning Madonna for too much sexuality. All that must come from the US.

We talk of wars and it's always those damn Americans and their war machine. No hint of Canada's history of war.

And yes, when it comes to spying or betraying its own citizens... it's always those darn Americans. Canada didn't have anything to do with Japanese internment because Canada has human rights. The US doesn't. Canada has never had to spy on its citizens. Surely Canada didn't spy on the various Quebec separatist movement historically.

At the end of the day, it's as if people don't realize that historically Canada and the USA are very similar. Both led by old Europeans. Sure there are differences. And much has changed post WW2. But still remarkably the same.

Re:You Know They'll Roll Over!

[mdielmann]

The difference is, when your data is stored in the US, the US can pass laws saying that the data has to be handed over, and the companies holding it for you can't tell you. If it's in Canada, there are two options.

First, Canada rolls over and requires the data be sent to the US. Of course, we don't currently have laws to require that, or for us to be silent about it if it does happen. Granted, we have the notwithstanding clause [wikipedia.org], which allows plenty of leeway, but not so much that they can emplace gag orders or warrantless searches.

Second, the Canadian company holding your data knowingly and actively does all it can to stop the unlawful access of your data, and responds if there are attempted breaches. Note that this will not and can not happen in the US as things currently stand.

At worst, it will be no different from having your data in the US. At best, you may have actual corporate security.