Follow Slashdot stories on Twitter

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×
Social Networks News

'OK' is Now a Hate Symbol, the ADL Says (cnn.com) 495

The "OK" hand gesture is now a hate symbol, according to a new report by the Anti-Defamation League. From a report: The ADL added that symbol along with several others on Thursday to its long-standing database of slogans and symbols used by extremists. The finger-and-thumb OK sign is universally known for meaning everything is all right or approval of something. But the ADL says while not everyone means it to be hateful, the sign has been co-opted by the alt-right.
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

'OK' is Now a Hate Symbol, the ADL Says

Comments Filter:
  • by Dallas May ( 4891515 ) on Friday September 27, 2019 @10:23AM (#59242764)

    *ah crap*

    Sorry guys. It just slipped out. No hate here.

    • Re: (Score:2, Insightful)

      Saying "OK" still OK; flashing the symbol is what they consider a hate symbol now!

      All a bit silly, and it did indeed start out as a joke; although now really is used as a hate symbol by some, which in itself seems silly.

      Unlike the swastika which (in the west at least) has had long term damage done to it (despite originally being a wholesome symbol before the Nazi's coopted it); I suspect the damage to the "ok hand-signal" is temporary. Give it 5 years and it will go back to meaning what it always has. It'

      • by Revek ( 133289 ) on Friday September 27, 2019 @11:02AM (#59242988)

        I'm afraid they can go fuck themselves. Lots of hand signals are considered offensive in different parts of the world. That particular one isn't here and never will be. They can be wrong about it all they want. I will continue to use it for OK as I have done since I was a child. They can change their perceptions, don't expect me to for their comfort and validation.

        • Re: (Score:3, Insightful)

          by Shaitan ( 22585 )

          "They can change their perceptions, don't expect me to for their comfort and validation."

          That attitude makes you a hater. Be careful expressing that. People are being forced to resign from media, academia, and other positions for expressing nothing more than what you said here. Stop paying attention for just a decade because you are busy in the work, eat, sleep cycle and not staying trendy and pretty much everything you say and do will be offensive and evil.

          Just last night my little brother put on "You don'

          • by LynnwoodRooster ( 966895 ) on Friday September 27, 2019 @12:29PM (#59243450) Journal
            Adam Sandler and Zohan withers in comparison to Mel Brooks and Blazing Saddles. You want to get the trigglypuffs foaming at the mouth? Blazing Saddles. Seriously, if every one of those SJWs had to watch it once a year, we'd be a much more mellow, more "live and let live" society...
      • by Strill ( 6019874 ) on Friday September 27, 2019 @11:09AM (#59243018)

        It's not used as a hate symbol by anyone. It's used specifically in response to articles like these, so that people will think that white supremacists have any power. The only power they actually have is what the media gives them.

      • by greythax ( 880837 ) on Friday September 27, 2019 @12:44PM (#59243526)

        I think what they are trying to point out is that there are online trolls who use the Okay finger gestures as a anti semantic sign, which, they are right about, not that EVERY use of the okay symbol is racist. It's so that when people see a strangely childlike drawing of pepe flashing the OK in response to an article about Israel online, they will understand the context, which you wouldn't normally understand unless you frequent /pol/.

    • Re: (Score:3, Insightful)

      I still want to know why Zionist Jewish Americans in the alt-right are considered anti-semitic.

  • by sinij ( 911942 ) on Friday September 27, 2019 @10:25AM (#59242766)
    Alt-right likes eating cheese. It follows that cheese has been co-opted by the alt-right. Therefore, eating cheese is now a hate crime.
    • by Holi ( 250190 ) on Friday September 27, 2019 @10:27AM (#59242780)
    • by pyrrho ( 167252 )

      Well the swastika is really a Hindu symbol... when you take something over and make it a famous hate symbol... you fuck over that thing pretty good. I.e. Hitler also ruined a perfectly good comedic mustache. I blame the Nazis.

      • by MBGMorden ( 803437 ) on Friday September 27, 2019 @10:46AM (#59242906)

        Sometimes you have to consider the level of things. 4-chan jokingly posting some images doesn't quite raise to the same level as if they put the "OK" hand symbol on weapons of war and then conquering multiple countries and systematically mass-murdering millions of people.

      • There's an interesting letter that JRR Tolkien wrote in which he condemns the Nazi for perverting Northern European culture and civilization by associating itself so closely with Germanic myth. It's a sad thing when the hate-filled co-opt symbolism that predates them, and indeed it can pervert it. Wagner did much the same thing with his anti-Semitic views. It's hard to listen to his music, which, as much as Tolkien, celebrated Germanic culture, without realizing that this great mind was stained by evil view

      • by IMightB ( 533307 )

        Its also important to remember, for the original Buddhist swastika, the "bent" arms go left (counter clockwise from the top), the Nazi Swastika, the arms bend to the right... (clockwise)

        • by Megol ( 3135005 )

          The use of the swastika in India predates Buddhism and the arms can be rotated both ways.

      • by mysidia ( 191772 )

        Its something else that people remember Hitler by some generic symbol, but forget all about the Armenian genocide [youtu.be] that came to the world years just before Hitler's insanity.

        Only because people are stupid and ridiculously focus on the symbols used by a past regime which has been extinguished. The Nazi party was extinguished, so there is no reason the design shouldn't be reclaimed and used for good --- Crush hate by appropriating messages that are hateful and make it a symbol in support of the victims

      • So, If a Hindu couple asks a Jewish-owned bakery to make a wedding cake that has that good-luck symbol on it, and the Jewish owned bakery refuses, who gets thrown to the mob? (Answer SHOULD be: the Jewish owner politely refuses and explains if needed. The Hindu couple respects that wish and finds another bakery.)
    • Hindus find it extremely irritating in the West that one of their holy symbols which means Good Luck is looked at weirdly when they put it on new Cars or Apartment doorways.
      The Swastika was a holy symbol for 3000 years before Hitler coopted it and now its verbotten.

      • The Swastika was a holy symbol for 3000 years before Hitler coopted it and now its verbotten.

        The Hindu "swastika [wikipedia.org]" goes the other direction. I guess you can't expect too many people to notice the difference though. I think it is ironic though that Antifa has decided to use the same colors [twimg.com] as the Nazis.

      • Next up, the ying/yang because there are only two genders. BTW, why does apple have hate symbols on the iphone?
      • Hindus find it extremely irritating in the West that one of their holy symbols which means Good Luck is looked at weirdly when they put it on new Cars or Apartment doorways.
        The Swastika was a holy symbol for 3000 years before Hitler coopted it and now its verbotten.

        Verboten? Visit Nepal or far western China. Swastiks (no ending 'a') are all over the place on temples and graveyards.

    • What else floats?
    • You think cheese is bad? Think about breathing! 100% of alt-righters breathe! Be a good little progressive being of indeterminate gender and stop breathing! Else you are just enabling the alt-right and their hateful CO2 production!
      • You think cheese is bad? Think about breathing! 100% of alt-righters breathe!

        Yes, but they breathe through their mouths; I breathe through my nose usually.

    • by beepsky ( 6008348 ) on Friday September 27, 2019 @11:03AM (#59242990)
      Unironically, some people think milk is now a symbol of white supremacy, since some alt-righters were seen drinking milk publicly, allegedly to assert their dominance and superiority over lesser, lactose intolerant races.
      Lmao, I feel like these people need to realize that the "alt-right" are just doing this stuff to fuck with them because it's funny.
  • by KalvinB ( 205500 ) on Friday September 27, 2019 @10:28AM (#59242784) Homepage

    The left is scraping the bottom of the barrel trying to find a reason for everyone and their cat to be offended.

    The ADL is doing a fantastic job of exemplifying how racism and bigotry foster themselves: someone you don't like does something, use that something to label millions of people in a negative way.

    The ADL wants everyone to hate the millions of people who use the ok sign because the ADL is run by bigots.

  • Not universal (Score:5, Informative)

    by isj ( 453011 ) on Friday September 27, 2019 @10:28AM (#59242786) Homepage

    The "OK" sign means , "evil eye", "asshole" or "worth nothing" in some cultures.

    See more at wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/... [wikipedia.org]

  • Stupid (Score:2, Interesting)

    by Anonymous Coward
    So now all the alt-right has to do is co-opt the rainbow flag or the star of david and see how the ADL tries to split hairs there or maybe just fall back to giving people the finger?
    Will the ADL find that people say that Israel is run by evil Jews a hateful statement?
    Where does this insanity end? Speech is speech. Yes, sometimes certain patterns of words are offensive along with emoji combination and pictographs. But sometimes a bowl haircut emoji or an OK symbol is just that. Or are we going to ban D
  • If it's a hate OK or an okay OK?
    Is thumbs down now an anti-hate symbol?

  • It depends on how you do it, to whom, and in what context. Which is why I have never understood this Anglo-Saxon penchant for making a point of saying 'please' when making a request: it is very ease to say (or even write) 'please' - complying with the convention - while at the same time being utterly contemptuous. And vice-versa, one can be very respectful and considerate without having to use that silly marker.
  • by StandardCell ( 589682 ) on Friday September 27, 2019 @10:34AM (#59242826)
    Neither of these organizations have any credibility any more, nor are they in any way authoritative, when they fall for a 4chan troll. What it does do is bolster their "narrative" to incriminate and stigmatize anyone who uses it.

    But if you're from another culture where it means something other than "Ok" or what the ADL/CNN claims it is, that must make the ADL or CNN actually racist.
  • by fahrbot-bot ( 874524 ) on Friday September 27, 2019 @10:34AM (#59242830)
    OK -- damn -- Okay, now how am I suppose to address mail to Oklahoma?
  • Doing up in the air, fingers up, and perhaps accompanied by a smile or wink is just saying "OK".

    Doing it down low, fingers pointed down, and looking like black people just peed in your cereal is "alt-right".

  • The OK sign is universally used in diving - time to select a new sign? Thumbs up won't work, perhaps the middle finger will be less offensive than the OK sign.

    • The OK sign is universally used in diving - time to select a new sign?

      To be fair, most people I know that do a lot of diving are white, sounds like those racist divers were ahead of the trend here in coopting the OK sign.

  • Comment removed based on user account deletion
  • ADL is a fucking huge pathetic excuse of a joke. Let me guess, they didn't get enough donations from their regular hucksterism so they need to gin up the boogy man more to scare people into donating.

    Look how many racists there are because we define everyone as racist. Donate to us to not be called a racist.

  • by Computershack ( 1143409 ) on Friday September 27, 2019 @10:42AM (#59242882)
    I swear Millennials are the most pathetic generation there has ever been. They literally spend their entire time trying to find things to offend them. Not only that if they have heard something may be offensive to them on somewhere like the TV or Facebook if they've missed it they'll go seek it out to watch it so they can be offended and can complain to the authorities about being offended by something they didn't see until they'd decided to go see it after being told it would offend them .
    • by XxtraLarGe ( 551297 ) on Friday September 27, 2019 @11:00AM (#59242970) Journal

      They literally spend their entire time trying to find things to offend them.

      It's one of the symptoms of affluenza [merriam-webster.com] (definition A).

    • by Brett Buck ( 811747 ) on Friday September 27, 2019 @11:04AM (#59243002)

      they'll go seek it out to watch it so they can be offended and can complain to the authorities about being offended

              The concept that they think "The Authorities" are somehow responsible to protect them from being offended is so fundamentally unAmerican, not to mention pathetic, that it makes be despair for the future. "The Authorities" are actually there to, at least indirectly, to *make sure someone has the right to offend you*, not prevent it.

  • by sdinfoserv ( 1793266 ) on Friday September 27, 2019 @10:43AM (#59242888)
    This is why we can't have nice things... eventually, someone, somewhere will "feel" offended because someone else has something nice and it will become a crime.
  • by Dunbal ( 464142 ) * on Friday September 27, 2019 @10:51AM (#59242928)
    If I say "It's OK to be white" by making the "OK" hand sign at the same time, does this make being white not be a hate crime now?
  • That they now have to go to extremes to drag every last inch of "perceived" prejudice and display it as though the next holocaust is already underway!

    I don't mind a little hyperbole for good measure, but this is a sign of a poor mental state of these folks. They feel icy gripe of irrelevance reaching for them and they are fighting back in ridiculous ways.

    Sadly, it is exactly this kind of behavior that drives that irrelevance more any anything. What happens to any cause when you water it down with accusati

  • I'm sure these guys have an appropriate replacement signal to use for next time I go diving and I want to check with my buddy on how they are doing.

    And no, they cannot use thumbs up since that means, well, "Up".

  • No it isn't (Score:5, Insightful)

    by jwhyche ( 6192 ) on Friday September 27, 2019 @11:00AM (#59242966) Homepage

    No its not. Nether is the bowl cut, even thought it is a bit dorky. Time to tell these little groups with axe to grind that everything is about them.

  • by TsuruchiBrian ( 2731979 ) on Friday September 27, 2019 @12:37PM (#59243498)

    It turns out many hate groups in the United States have been communicating using the English language. I am shocked and saddened to find out that something so ubiquitous and essential to our way of life has been co-opted by hate. All people of conscience are not obligated to start using a different hate free language if they haven't yet done so or to invent a new one if necessary, and pray that no hate groups decide to use it. This will be my final message in English.

    Bloop Floop Chewbacca,
    TsuruchiBrian

  • Context (Score:5, Insightful)

    by twocows ( 1216842 ) on Friday September 27, 2019 @02:27PM (#59244040)
    Speaking to this specific case, what happened was trolls (in the sense of people looking to stir up trouble) from 4chan's politics board (a genuinely hateful place) wanted to illustrate how anti-hate groups are over-eager to apply the label of "hate" to even largely benign symbols and speech. A stopped clock's right twice a day, as they say. The ADL is absolutely over-eager to apply this label (try reading the list on their website if you're skeptical) and in doing so is making themselves look ridiculously overzealous.

    I think it's important, in the pursuit of trying to challenge discriminatory speech or behavior, to be very judicious in the use of the "hate" label and to assume good faith when possible. Using it too frequently and too broadly weakens its meaning, and abusing it to attack well-intentioned people who don't understand the situation with this symbol just pushes people away. I think it's self-evident when someone's using the "OK" gesture for its original meaning versus as some kind of dogwhistle for hate speech; the context should make it pretty obvious.

Some people manage by the book, even though they don't know who wrote the book or even what book.

Working...