Want to read Slashdot from your mobile device? Point it at m.slashdot.org and keep reading!

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×
Youtube

Russia To Slow YouTube Speeds (yahoo.com) 71

Russia admitted that it's deliberately slowing YouTube's loading speeds and said it plans to throttle the download speeds on the Google platform by up to 70% by the end of next week. Russia is taking this stand in response to Google's refusal to comply with the demands of the Russian authorities, local lawmaker Alexander Khinshtein said. From a report: Khinshtein, the head of the State Duma's Information Policy Committee, claimed that the move is "not aimed against Russian users, but against the administration of a foreign resource that still believes that it can violate and ignore our legislation with impunity."
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Russia To Slow YouTube Speeds

Comments Filter:
  • by NoMoreDupes ( 8410441 ) on Friday July 26, 2024 @02:14PM (#64658078)

    Khinshtein, the head of the State Duma's Information Policy Committee, claimed that the move is "not aimed against Russian users

    And yet the Russian users will end up having to live with the degraded service; does this fucking idiot seriously think users will blame Google, when it'll be super-easy for Google to state (and prove) the Russian users' own government is responsible for it?

    • Re: (Score:3, Informative)

      by dragisha ( 788 )

      Just like the Chinese have been doing for ages now. I think users will cope and gradually move to other services. Some will use proxies just like the Chinese do, but in the long term - local services will prevail.

      It is a good thing Russia cannot send SWAT teams to enforce their laws like some other country did to the MEGA upload guy and his New Zealand company.

    • Re: What an idiot (Score:3, Insightful)

      by fjorder ( 5219645 )
      Of course they will blame Google, just like some people think Trump is the president
    • by taustin ( 171655 )

      He's Putin's Bagdad Bob [wikipedia.org].

      And he has to know it.

    • They will blame who they're told to.

    • They will blame their government and not Google, yes. But they will use the local services the government controls, because those work and YouTube doesn't. Putin gets what he wants, and he won't care if the people believe the official line as to who is to blame or not.

      • That might be a hard pill to swallow. It would be kind of like telling them that they're not allowed to have Adidas track suits anymore.

        • That might be a hard pill to swallow. It would be kind of like telling them that they're not allowed to have Adidas track suits anymore.

          But then a polonium cocktail or Dioxin soup might get them in line.

      • If the Russian people won't act to change their own government then they kinda deserve the enshitification.
      • Putin is a trained Soviet KGB agent, his father was well entrenched into the Soviet government, he knows exactly how these things work, just as when Lenin came to power, the majority of people will not believe this can be happening (again) until millions end up disappearing and hundreds per day wash up on the shores of the Volga with bullet holes to the back of the head.

        Putin has not been shy about wanting to re-establish a Russian Communist empire, he believes himself to be a Lenin type figure.

  • by presidenteloco ( 659168 ) on Friday July 26, 2024 @02:23PM (#64658108)
    You mean the legislation that says don't show people what's really going on? And don't let people utter their true opinions, if their opinions are against your government? That legislation?

    Wankers.
  • by Baron_Yam ( 643147 ) on Friday July 26, 2024 @02:34PM (#64658142)

    I'm sure Putin would love to block foreign Internet entirely and replace it with Kremlin-approved and controlled Russian servers.

    It's interesting that he hasn't, because it means he doesn't think he'd get away with it.

    • Because of the military-related sanctions, I doubt YouTube can make much money in Russia anyhow. YouTube might not care. Russia probably needs it working more than Google because YouTube is where all the tutorials on fixing Microsoft crap is.

      • by caseih ( 160668 )

        I despise youtube tutorials in general for that sort of thing. At least we can now ask AI to watch the video and summarize it for us in easy-to-follow text bullet points.

    • by ksw_92 ( 5249207 )

      I wouldn't mind it if all of Russia was BGP null-routed. It'd cut down on all the horse crap attacks we have to deal with. Imagine Russian hackers having to leave Russia to gain access to their bot farms and the fun that certain rendition teams could have...

  • They recently purchased my Comcast simulator to achieve this.

  • by bryanandaimee ( 2454338 ) on Friday July 26, 2024 @02:40PM (#64658156) Homepage
    I thought I would have to read deeply in to the article to find out what the mysterious "demands" were. Nope, here's the original title: "Russia to slow YouTube speeds after Google refuses to comply with censorship" Was that so hard to say in the summary?
  • by Wokan ( 14062 ) on Friday July 26, 2024 @02:51PM (#64658180) Journal

    Isn't Google supposed to be not doing business with Russia?

    • by jonadab ( 583620 )
      The sanctions don't require tech companies to block Russian users from accessing content. Google is _allowing_ Russian users to continue to watch YouTube videos. But they're not censoring the ones the Russian government doesn't like. So Russia responds by making YouTube videos load slowly in Russia

      They're probably hoping that Russian users will switch to a Russian video-hosting platform, but can anyone even *name* one of those? I cannot. I know the name of a Russian web search engine, but I don't know
    • by Anonymous Coward

      Google and YouTube doesn't show ads to Russian viewers

  • Putin is weak (Score:5, Insightful)

    by rsilvergun ( 571051 ) on Friday July 26, 2024 @03:20PM (#64658274)
    The fact that they can't just ban it shows how weak Putin is. His economy is close to collapse with multiple experts estimating he's got about 5 months left before he either pulls out of Ukraine and tries to undo as much of the damage he's done as possible or before he gets taken out by a rival.

    He can easily handle one or two credible threats to his dictatorship but when the economy collapses he's going to have them from all sides and sooner or later one of them is going to get him and he knows it.

    This is why dictators suck. They're good at staying in power not at running a country
    • by HiThere ( 15173 )

      I'm not convinced that ANYBODY, or any system of government, if good at running a country. Certainly laissez faire won't work beyond about the very small village level. (It even has trouble WITHIN a nuclear family.)

      That said, some kings have occasionally done an acceptable job. (I'm not claiming this is true of most, or even many, of them.) And a king is pretty much like a dictator. So it's not inherent the "dictator" position unless you think that inherited tradition is what made the occasional "good

      • Tyrants (aka "kings") are not a solution at all.

        Firstly, all the enlightened royal houses of history that I can think of delegated decision making to a class of competent civil servants with a strong sense of duty. So the kings themselves were pretty much just parasites.

        Secondly, royal succession is a real problem that causes endless wars. In a nutshell, wherever there is a king without democracy, it is impossible to replace a bad ruler peacefully. The only way is violence and lots of it. That's why king

  • by NoMoreDupes ( 8410441 ) on Friday July 26, 2024 @04:13PM (#64658416)

    [Retard] Alexander Khinshtein said: "not aimed against Russian users, but against the administration of a foreign resource that still believes that it can violate and ignore our legislation with impunity."

    Oh, you mean like how Putin violates and ignores international law with its illegal war crimes in Ukraine? Just like that?

  • by smooth wombat ( 796938 ) on Friday July 26, 2024 @04:17PM (#64658430) Journal
    When you can't let the truth about your actions be known.

    This is just another in a long series of edicts the muscovite midget has implemented to keep the truth from the Russian people. He certainly doesn't want them to know about the 560,000 russians killed, wounded, captured, or missing [businessinsider.com] since February 2022. He certainly doesn't want them to know how all Russian ships have fled Crimea [newsweek.com] after a third of the Black Sea Fleet was either sunk or damaged. How Ukraine can hit Russian oil depots and refineries [reuters.com] almost at will. Or jailing people who tell the truth [cbsnews.com] about how badly Russia is losing in its war against Ukraine.

    This is just another attempt by Putin to cling to power before his house of cards folds under him.
    • Compared to the stated objectives, Russia is indeed losing very badly in Ukraine.

      Unfortunately, Putin has a lot of warm bodies to sacrifice and Russia isn't losing from Ukraine's perspective: Russia still controls Ukrainian territory and is even slightly expanding what they've taken. Russia is still destroying Ukrainian infrastructure and killing its people.

      • Russia is losing 3 to 5 people for every Ukrainian killed. They may have more warm bodies, but they don't have an endless supply. It is already feeling the effects of losing so many people by businesses running short of people to do jobs.

        Putin is doing everything he can to avoid another mandatory conscription. The last time he did it hundreds of thousands of people fled the country. Doing it a second time would have almost the same result.

        • At this point, I am absolutely rooting for the fall of Russia, even with all the chaos that will ensue.

          The last time we tried to accept Russia into the modern world, it used the opportunity to stir up shit everywhere. Now I just want it gone, along with any citizens who can't let go of the old ways.

    • When you can't let the truth about your actions be known. This is just another attempt by Putin to cling to power before his house of cards folds under him.

      Slashdot should start posting all manner of anti-Pootin' stuff and see if we can get banned there.

    • The same was said about Lenin and his Bolshevik Revolution, any day now, any day now, as people hid their wealth, got shot for daring to say something and women between 15 and 25 were socialized.

  • This shows just how weak the Russian government really is. They have to run a propaganda campaign against YouTube and then incrementally slow it down so when they finally block it people will accept it and not shit all over the state.

  • by dsgrntlxmply ( 610492 ) on Friday July 26, 2024 @05:15PM (#64658576)
    Cat videos will sound like the MGM lion.
  • Is Russia asking for things to be done that exceed what other countries have requested and had Google has done?

    Well, we know that Google is used by the US State Department as a tool for regime change operations (see when google met wikileaks). So I expect there's probably some reason why we're being fed the usual hysterics.

    • by Tablizer ( 95088 )

      we know that Google is used by the US State Department as a tool for regime change operations

      It's not working.

  • ... by inserting advertisements into videos. So outside of Russia, one needs a proper ad-blocker or alternative client to circumvent the shitty slowdown, and inside Russia one needs a working VPN (but probably less of an ad-blocker, assuming that Russian companies currently cannot buy ads on youtube).
  • 1 in 5 Russians already use VPNs and the rest will simply receive 480p content which works on as little as 1Mb broadband perfectly smoothly. This will have zero impact on Russians who already don't pay for their media. It will only hurt Google who will lose whatever little ad revenue they might have received from people seeing ads for whichever few businesses still traded with the Russian market.

C'est magnifique, mais ce n'est pas l'Informatique. -- Bosquet [on seeing the IBM 4341]

Working...