Linus Is A Hero 357
oever writes "The dutch broadcaster KRO has chosen 365 modern saints or heros. One of them is Linus Torvalds, chosen for his work in on Linux and 'Open Source'. Too bad RMS or Saint Ignuciuis he wasn't chosen, even though he was recommended."
hmmm.. (Score:2, Funny)
Re:hmmm.. (Score:2, Interesting)
Tina turner: for overcomming humiliation
James Taylor: for getting rid of drugs
Nyh!
Re:hmmm.. (Score:2, Insightful)
They smoke weed!
Re:hmmm.. (Score:2)
Re:hmmm.. (Score:2)
Re:hmmm.. (Score:2)
Re:hmmm.. (Score:2)
Church of Linux! (Score:5, Funny)
This is going to make those "it's not a religious" arguments a lot harder!
Dear God, save us from your followers (Score:2)
Re:Church of Linux! (Score:2)
Is it true that you had to assemble your own chairs, but once you do you can take them home and use them for a variety of purposes?
Just thought I'd ask. I'm from the Church of Windows. Our chairs come pre-assembled and are quite comfortable, but there's a very specific commandment about using the chair in a particular way.
Per-Seat Licensing (Score:2)
Re:Church of Linux! (Score:2)
Then there are those passages in the Microsoft Bible that require each paritioner to lubricate his anus before attending services.
Pretty strict with that collection plate too.
Re:Sects, Sects, Sects! (Score:2)
Re:Sects, Sects, Sects! (Score:2)
Which incidentally is closed to the way Linus says it [kernel.org]
Obviously, he has a Swedish accent, so he says it with the longer ee sound, but converting that into UK English, it would go from leenuks, to lihnuks. Lienuks is due to the Americans changing the word - there are some examples of this in other words, but I can't remember them.
I'd have read it but... (Score:3, Offtopic)
That rant's over for now, so I'll just have to ask for somebody to get a text list or something.
Re:I'd have read it but... (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:I'd have read it but... (Score:2, Insightful)
It also brings us www.homestarrunner.com.
If you think I'm going to give up strongbad's e-mail in order to "unchoke the flow of free information" or to get rid of a few ads you've got another thing coming. Besides flash works on almost any device so I don't see how it chokes the flow, if it can flow anywhere.
Re:I'd have read it but... (Score:2)
Does it work on text-to-speech or braille.
Is it adjustable for colour-blindness?
Is it indexable/searchable?
How do I set a bookmark at a certain point in Flash?
(I'm aware that you wrote almost)
> It also brings us www.homestarrunner.com.
Yes, very informative.
So, what kind of information do you think one cannot convey through the internet by the means of text and pictures, but through Flash-media?
Re:I'd have read it but... (Score:2)
Re:I'd have read it but... (Score:2)
Well, I don't consider this as a problem
But to quote from the post you were replying to:
>>> It chokes the flow of free information and turns pages (of information) into giant full-screen animated talking commercials.
And your reply:
>> I don't see how it chokes the flow,
Entertainment is a different story.
I won't deny that Homestarrunner is entertaining and flash can generate pretty amusing pages and good looking ones.
Re:I'd have read it but... (Score:2)
Re:I'd have read it but... (Score:2)
Re:I'd have read it but... (Score:2)
Everything important in life I learned from Jake [romp.com]. A true American hero.
Don't let the
Re:I'd have read it but... (Score:2)
If Flash is not evil, then how do you:
a) Cut and paste text out of a flash page, say: a phone number? (Yes, I've been facted with that problem more than once.)
b) Turn off the animation?
Re:I'd have read it but... (Score:2)
a) Cut and paste text out of a flash page, say: a phone number? (Yes, I've been facted with that problem more than once.)
The same way you cut and paste out of non-evil jpgs / pngs / gifs (take your pick).
b) Turn off the animation?
By not downloading the plugin? Surely you won't need it of it's all evil.
wrong story (Score:2)
Oh wait
Re:I'd have read it but... (Score:2)
Oh geez. Talk about misappropriation of blame.
Flash is not the problem. It's the content makers. Your beef is with them. Flash is just a tool. It is a very sophisticated tool, but like with 3D rendering, not everybody is a star with it. It's just like pop-ups. Nobody's yelling at Microsoft or Netscape because of their popup support, they're yelling at the people who abuse them.
Don't you have to be dead to be canonized? (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Don't you have to be dead to be canonized? (Score:3, Funny)
Nope, just a cannon. They do it in the circus all the time...
St. Alphonzo's Pancake Breakfast (Score:2, Funny)
Damned plugins (Score:2)
All I get is a huge grey block in the middle of a black screen.
BONO?! (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:BONO?! (Score:2)
Re:BONO?! (Score:3, Informative)
Bono has actually done a HUGE amount of work to save small countries from financial collapse. He meets with government officials in the USA (and now a few other big countries too, although I can't recall which ones), and persuades them to forgive billions upon billions of dollars in debt. Because of Bono, some small counties have been able to remain in existence.
Re:BONO?! (Score:2)
You ought to take your own advice. You cite only 1 recent event as a way to discount Bono's efforts, but conveniently ignore the fact that he's done dozens of events like this over the past ten years, and some have indeed resulted in huge amounts of debt relief. Happily, KRO has obviously done more research than you have, and found Bono's contributions substantial and real enough to warrant being on the list.
Nutcase (Score:2)
This guy is on crack.
Re:Nutcase (Score:2)
No clue about Springsteen, though.
Re:Nutcase (Score:2)
Guess that makes him qualified to moderate here ("moderators on crack" postings) :-)
Re:Nutcase (Score:2)
If Linus is such a hero (Score:2)
Bird (Score:3, Funny)
I always knew he rocked, that's why I named my cockatiel after him!
I also named my fish after Alan Cox... but the fish died, so no wonder he didn't make the list
Good choice! (Score:2)
Good thing it wasn't the other way around. Even though naming your cockatiel after Alan has a certain aliteratory appeal, you don't want to be chasing after him when he runs away in the neighborhood yelling "Here, cox! Get over here, cox!! Com'ere boy!! That's a good cox!".
"modern" saint? (Score:5, Funny)
Re:"modern" saint? (Score:2)
Re:"modern" saint? (Score:2)
Dude... that inspired me to create a comic book.
"I am Default Man! Watch how quickly I can install software! OkOkOkOkOkOk done!"
Open source hero weenie. (Score:2)
I want the pattern to his superhero outfit released so I can see how I stack up.
RMS - movie hero? (Score:2)
Also in there... (Score:2)
Uh oh, wait until RMS gets ahold of them! (Score:2)
The hero's now working for PALLADIUM (Score:3, Interesting)
And today, the hero is working for one of the companies behind Palladium
http://www.theinquirer.net/?article=6487 [theinquirer.net]
I posted this on the 'linuxnewbie' forums some time ago, but it curiously disappeared. I've received no mail from the moderators and I've really verified that my message had really been posted. My interpretation is that some linuxnewbie moderator was a Linus fan.
Why don't we have an award like this in the US? (Score:2)
Looking through the pictures on that website, these look like people I would actually like to meet (save the black guy with sunglasses and purple hair) as opposed to the plastic celebrities we're constantly bombarded with by the media in the States.
Stop jumping up and down... (Score:2)
And let's face it, people like Linus as a representative and leader of the kernel development, but I suspect nobody on the kernel mailinglist will call Linus a saint
(Sorry to burst your bubble...)
Simon
Linus (Score:4, Funny)
A hero.
Superpowers:
Kernel strike - takes 10 turns, produces a kernel that combined with a set of GNU tools decreases enemy share on the server market.
E-mail - takes 0 turns, gives additional activity to every geek character on LKML. This multiplies by 100 if re-posted on Slashdot.
Flying - well, not yet.
I know this won't be popular... (Score:2)
I know this will probably activate the froth glands of you zealots, but please read this whole post first. I don't know who compiled this list, but I suspect that if those people were left off, it was done so deliberately, despite their obvious contributions to the development of the internet.
As unpopular as they and their creations are to a lot of people here, I think it's unfair to ignore how they were able to bring the internet to millions of users who, without Windows and/or AOL, would have never been able to do so.
Re:I know this won't be popular... (Score:3, Interesting)
As unpopular as they and their creations are to a lot of people here, I think it's unfair to ignore how they were able to bring the internet to millions of users who, without Windows and/or AOL, would have never been able to do so.
Apple+Prodigy, or Apple+CompuServe, would have done it. AOL's real genius (whether they were Steve Case's ideas, or more likely those of his staff) was making the Internet connection in AOL work more simply than in the other online services, and in coming out with the unlimited connection plan when he did (despite the horrible user experience that led to for the first year or so after the change). Microsoft's real genius wrt the Internet (whether they were Bill Gates's ideas, or more likely those of his staff) was in recognizing the threat that Netscape posed to the Microsoft model and quickly leveraging free code into a "dumped" product (IE 2; don't talk to me about IE 1) that usurped Netscape's place and either per accidens or purposefully (the latter would be more complimentary to Microsoft) integrated the user's experience of the Web and the 'Net with the user's experience of the operating system.
In some ways, what MS is talking about now is what Sun was talking about 5 years ago. Moving the real work onto the network and off the desktop.
Re:I know this won't be popular... (Score:2)
I'm still not sure that letting millions of ignorant users on was a good idea in the first place. How many times does one have to get AIMs or ICQs of "ASL" or "Come see me and my friends naked XXX" before it becomes obvious that the glorious internet, that sacred educational frontier, has become nothing more than a cesspool where if you know where to go, you can actually find real information? Let's face it, easy access is good, idiot access isn't necessarily good.
3 of the 4 Beatles (Score:4, Funny)
He isn't as visible as the others; but he's done a lot of post-Beatles work for charity.
Cheers, Ringo.
Re:3 of the 4 Beatles (Score:2)
Cheers, Ringo
Re:3 of the 4 Beatles (Score:2)
--
Re:3 of the 4 Beatles (Score:2)
"In the world? He's not even the best drummer in the band."
toodles
marty
I hate flash (Score:2)
Quick Translation (Score:4, Funny)
The free Linux-software developed itself the past few years as a solid comptetitor against Windows. The Fin Linus Torvalds is the hero of the 'open source'- movement.
The Finse student Linus Torvalds wrote in 1991 a first version of Linux. Torvalds asked a few friend-programmers to have a look at and comment on his creation. Thuswas born a cooperation that still today leads tp continuous improvement of the operating system.
Meanwhile, there is a core of at least 1000 internetusers continuously polishing linux.
besides this core, there are many one-time contributions. Thru nightly chat-sessions the discussion about possible additions and improvements of this common good are worked out.
initially, linux turned out to be an OS for fanatic hobbyists, usualy working in academic situations. At the end of the 90s, linux started rising in computer centers of lartge companies. System administrators download linux for free from the Net and use it 'en masse' as webserver, often without IT managers knowledge.
If problems come to light, they get notified in newsgroups all over the net, whereafter tenthousands of programmers are volunteering to help finding a solution.
The advantages of linux are numerous according to open-source fans. Mostly because it is free : in contrast with other software, no licences have to be paid, but rather it is freely downloadable.
Then they go on an nag about linus being gay, having a goatse affair with CmdrTaco in russia in a base that belongs to someone who has bad grammar (like me). Or something.
Re: (Score:2)
Re:Why Saint Ignuciuis didn't make the cut. (Score:2)
Stick to producing great software like GCC and give up on the music front. !PLEASE!!!
Shouldn't that be... (Score:2)
Where's Ringo? (Score:2)
Hrm, (Score:3, Informative)
Sure, I respect Linus for his work and contributions to the IT world and the "liberation" from propertairy software and unethical licenses. However, the REAL heroes on that page are two victims of "zinloos geweld" as we dutch people call it, or "senseless violence" if translated into english. These two people I'm talking about are René Steegmans and Meindert Tjoelker (both on the same page as Linus) who were killed for no reason at all. Maybe not such a big thing in the US, but remember that the Netherlands is about 1/232th the size of the US. (according to the CIA factbook, ahem) Meindert Tjoelker was killed when trying to calm a fight between a few people and René Steegmans was killed when he questioned a bunch of guys wether they had any respect for an old lady who they almost ran over on scooters. They are real heroes to us Dutchies.
Interesting list, but... (Score:2)
And what about Tim Berners-Lee? (Score:2, Insightful)
A zombie!!! A zombie!!! (Score:3, Funny)
Saint Linus!?!?!? Blasphemy!!! (Score:2, Funny)
Thou shalt not have other Saint Linus before the one true Saint Linus.
Of course he wasn't a saint! (Score:2)
Of course he wasn't! He's no lowly saint, he's nothing less than the Second Coming! He'll tell you himself!
Oh, wait... GNU/Second Coming.
Shouldn't that be... (Score:2)
--Joey
Such pictures should not be linked to. (Score:2)
Yee-Hah (Score:2)
Role Model Maybe (Score:2)
I seem to remember being instructed as to what a hero is in basic training. But I never understood it, not really.
Not until I met one. Two holes in his chest and fighting for his own life at that point. But he saved two lives prior. That is a hero.
A hero is the man who runs into a blazing fire in order to save your sorry ass.
A hero is the lady who jumps into an ice cold river to save your child.
A role model is someone who writes a free Unix like kernel and gives it to the world for free.
I want to be like Linus some day. I hope I never have to be a hero.
Congrads for Linus (Score:2)
Then again, there's Bono & David Bowie, so perhaps it isn't as bad as all that.
Interesting Dutch perspective (Score:2)
I think they chose some Americans we wouldn't have chosen. Cosby is one example. He's an OK comedian, and I loved Fat Albert back in the day and all, but still not exactly a heroic figure in my book. More interestingly, they picked FDR and did not mention Churchill. If Americans made the list, I suspect the reverse would have been true. (Even back during WWII, it was remarked that the US and Britan could switch leaders, and both would be happier).
census (Score:2)
Re:Just ignorance, nothing more (Score:2)
Methinks RMS deserves to be much more favourably viewed, if not for his philosophy (it is very revolutionary even today) or his social contributions (FSF), at least for his technical contributions (emacs, gcc, the whole GNU toolset).
Modding the parent as troll is very unfair.
S
Re:Just ignorance, nothing more (Score:2)
Maybe eventually Hurd will displace Linux, maybe eventually the *BSDs will displace them both; but for now, Linux + GNU is the crown jewel of Open Source.
But his obnoxiousness overshadows the rest. (Score:2, Insightful)
He'd garner far more respect for his technical contributions if he didn't make us accept his ravings^H^H^H^H^H^Hextreme socio-political opinions as a baseline for talking to him.
Fair or not, RMS the extremist cannot be separated from RMS the coder. And that limits the appeal of RMS the coder.
Re:Just ignorance, nothing more (Score:2)
This is not about computers, but culture in general and History in particular. History of computing, but bigger than computers and yet not technical at all.
BTW, has nothing to do with the Americas in general or the USNA in particular, as this is a Dutch site without even an English version.
He, he was not only the bootloader writer, he is the kernel writer and maintainer. The bootloaders are called LILO or GRUB, not Linux.
Re:Just ignorance, nothing more (Score:2)
No one says Tim Berners-Lee invented the Internet. I've never seen any media claim TBL invented the Internet. Everyone says, rightly, that he invented the World Wide Web (though I don't think they understand what that means, that he invented the set of protocols used by web browsers and web servers).
Besides, everyone knows that Al Gore invented the Internet.
In all seriousness, you've got everyone and his brother claiming to have invented the Internet, when what matters is who invented TCP/IP.
It is the same way with Linus and RMS, with RMS creating most of the base for Linux, but since Linus was the original bootloader writer, people assume he "invented" Linux, while overlooking the more important luminaries.
I think the Linux kernel is a lot more than a bootloader. Hurd was taking forever, and folks decided to try LT's Linux kernel with GNU's tools. And thus GNU/Linux was born.
Re:Just ignorance, nothing more (Score:2)
Re:Linux kernel did not need GCC/GNU/RMS (Score:3, Informative)
lcc [princeton.edu]
TenDRA [unsw.edu.au]
If not gcc, there would be even more free compilers. Writing a compiler is not as simple as writing another ICQ client, but it's still not rocket science.
Re:Linux kernel did not need GCC/GNU/RMS (Score:2)
You can compare the number of supported processors, but everything else - correctness, effectiveness, reliability, resource consumption - cannot be compared between different classes of sortware.
What I was trying to say is that the existence of gcc wasn't a precondition for Linux. Linus could have started his work on the kernel with some other compiler, even if it was slower, non-free, and non-portable.
Many projects changed the compiler between versions. BeOS switched from Metrowerks to gcc. It would not be impossible to switch Linux to gcc.
Re:Linux kernel did not need GCC/GNU/RMS (Score:2)
Which compiler built the first version of GCC?
Which compiler build that compiler's first version?
You can apply the same to an operating system kernel. That is what makes both very remarkable accomplishments, especially considering their success and abundance today.
Writing a compiler not that hard (Score:2)
Writing a compiler is not actually very difficult. Oh, it's not "hello world", but if you have a basic grounding in assembly and some documentation, it's quite doable for a single person to have a quite usable compiler for a simple language in a month.
Carnegie Mellon University (as well as many other universities) have a compilers course, in which you write a compiler, so many people actually do so each year.
Writing a compiler that does really good optimization, on the other hand, is very, very difficult.
And, last of all, benchmarking and tweaking a compiler is not trivial and takes a *huge* amount of time. If you're compiling for a really simple cacheless architecture, maybe it's a piece of cake, but trying to make a good x86 optimizing compiler (especially one for multiple generations of x86 processors) is a tremendous amount of work.
Re:Linux kernel did not need GCC/GNU/RMS (Score:4, Funny)
Re:Linux kernel did not need GCC/GNU/RMS (Score:2, Funny)
Re:Oh come on (Score:2)
Hm, I work for a company whose sole raison d'etre is doing just that - finding a cure for cancer. We use Linux extensively, and while we probably could've done without, it does make the whole operation a hell of a lot cheaper (which, for a startup in the current economic climate, does matter quite a bit) and my job somewhat easier (which in the end saves the company money as well).
The guy belongs in a looney bin, not on a list of hero nominees. Any good works RMS has done or continues to do are far outwieghed by his mental disorders.
I am afraid I fail to see the connection. Even if he is a satan worshipping misanthrope who kicks puppies just for fun, his works is still his work. Which, one could argue is a bit more infulential than Linus'. Linus created one project, a very large, very successful and very important project, but nonetheless a single project. RMS (arguably) got the whole Free Software thing off the ground in the first place, influencing (directly or indirectly, a lot or a little) every single other free project out there. Oh, and just how much use is the Linux kernel without, let's say, GCC (to pick an example)?
The guy has no respect for anyone or anything that doesn't believe as he does.
So? This isn't the "List of People Who Respect Others and are Nice To Their Mothers". I don't believe this is supposed to be some sort of popularity contest.
This just always gets on my tits; I mean, ok, so you seem to be slightly less of a jerk than RMS is, but are your accomplishments in the same proportion to his?
Re:Oh come on (Score:2)
Let's try to find out.
Do you use screwdrivers at work? I guess we better make the inventor of the screw driver a hero then.
The screwdriver is an important invention and quite essential for many technology oriented fields. However, it can also be considered to be fairly trivial, and there's a good chance that screwdrivers would be invented by someone else had the original inventor never bothered. I am not sure the same can be said about free operating systems / kernels / whatever.
And BTW yes I do think my contributions outweigh his however that is irrelevant to the conversation since I'm not nominated in the award.
Fair enough, though I do think they are quite relevant as they give you more of a solid position when attacking RMS.
By your definition Sadam is a hero because he's brought some economic relief to his people, nevermind the ones he's killed and tortured.
My definition made the distiction between people's accomplishments and their personalities. Your major problems with RMS seem to be that he is a "loon", is disrespectful of others and apparently prone to frothing. Killing people, on the other hand, is firmly in the realm of "real actions" rather than "attitude towards others".
Just go away, that was the most ridiculous post I have ever read in my life.
You have a four digit slashdot id, I refuse to believe that the above statement is true.
BTW, In that post I didn't actual claim that any one should or shouldn't be on any such list; merely trying to point out some differences in what they've done.
Re:Oh come on (Score:2, Insightful)
Stallman's contributions made the free software movement possible. As is stated below, he invented the wheel and gave it away for free. How exactly has Stallman hurt free software? The GNU license is its greatest protector. Unfortunately those who stands by their convictions are often labeled as crazy by those who disagree with them. Such is the case here.
I think we will find that history will treat Richard Stallman more kindly than he is treated in many contemporary fora. His concept is built to last. (Side note for you Ayn Rand fans-- I was in a conversation where someone asked "Who is the Howard Roark of the software world?". After Bill Gates was shot down, I found some consensus with RMS)
BTW what free software do _you_ use?
hahahaha (Score:2)
Stallman hasn't contributed anything nearly as great as you seem to think. RMS isn't the entire FSF movement, there are MILLIONS more people contributing a great deal EVERYDAY. You Stallman worshipers really astound me with your ignorance and blind devotion to a man who has proved time and time again to be nothing more than a school yard bully to other developers. The only other FSF figure head even remotely as looney as RMS is Theo from OpenBSD.
History wont even blink at RMS, nor Linus. This is just software, not some great political movement like you seem to think. 10 years from now OS's as we know them wont even be a blip on the radar screen.
What free software do I use? What the hell does that matter? Is this the part where I'm supposed to whip out my dick and measure it along side yours to see who's the bigger man?
oh excuse me (Score:2)
Re:Worst...post...ever (Score:2)
For those who don't know statistics, RMS is the square Root of the Mean of the Squares in a distribution. It's a great tool for physicists.
Re:Funny jibber-jabber all over that site! (Score:2)
At least they know the difference between Good and W.Bush..
Re:Visual Studio .NET (Score:2)
That's funny.
Someone pretending to be someone in my class.
Hee hee...
So, what course was it and who was the prof? Heck, what school do I go to?
Re:Weird choice (Score:2)