Interview with the Frag Dolls 93
Staci writes "KillerBetties.com, a site with a focus on the female gamer, is running a interview with three of the ladies that comprise the UbiSoft sponsored FragDolls FPS Team. Rhoulette, Jinx and Katscratch sat down with Nicole of KillerBetties to talk about the controversy surrounding their existence and connection with UbiSoft, how they feel about representing female gamers and a few other personal tidbits." From the article: "We wouldn't be the Frag Dolls if it weren't for Ubisoft, so promoting games is certainly a distinct part of what we do. However, all of us have our dreams for where we would like to see girl gamers a year from now. And as girl gamers ourselves, we can't really help but represent some of their interests and desires."
Thanks for this interview (Score:4, Funny)
I read this ias (Score:1, Funny)
I thought someone had created a new subdomain porn.slasdot.org.
Re:Cute and good at video games? (Score:1)
Re:Cute and good at video games? (Score:1)
More advice on these matters in my book, "Herding Deuces"
Re:Cute and good at video games? (Score:1)
Re:Cute and good at video games? (Score:2)
Rob (By "oddly," I mean "totally expectedly")
Re:Cute and good at video games? (Score:2)
Re:Cute and good at video games? (Score:2)
Re:Cute and good at video games? (Score:1)
Heh... Nice choice of ads... (Score:5, Interesting)
I don't know if anyone else got this ad, but when I pulled up the interview about woman gamers, I got a nice long banner ad for Anarchy Online next to it that read "I Got Implants Baby!", complete with an ingame female character in underwear. Another ad in the corner features the same ingame model, with the text "Play Me!"
Really goes well with a site "focused on girl gamers." Apparently their advertisers are focused on a certain subset of girl gamers...
(I'm assuming "I Got Implants Baby!" is a reference to something ingame that I don't get because I don't play the game, but still - it's kind of crude. It's the Internet, I've got other things available to satisfy the "oggling at women" need, that an MMORPG just isn't going to be able to offer. I always wonder about games that try to sell themselves using a hot ingame character - it's like they're trying to distract you with that, to get you to overlook something else, like the fact that the game sucks or something. Makes me wary.)
Re:Heh... Nice choice of ads... (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:Heh... Nice choice of ads... (Score:1)
Re:Heh... Nice choice of ads... (Score:3, Insightful)
if they wanted to focus on girls they'd get brad pitt or someone... though, it's all about PR and adverts, just think what 'clan' games they could play from bugisoft...
Re:Heh... Nice choice of ads... (Score:1)
Re:Heh... Nice choice of ads... (Score:4, Interesting)
There's nothing offensive about scantily clad women.
But promoting women as simple, sexual objects with unrealistic body proportions to sell a product to stupid men is offensive.
Many young men are so warped by the fake silicone and false stereotypes they have no idea what a real women is like. Hopefully these men won't breed.
It's offensive to most women that I know, and it's offensive to me as a man, because the coropations are trying to use sex to manipulate me. Sex is very primal, it is hard to ignore.
Re:Heh... Nice choice of ads... (Score:2)
I think the offense comes because it's a rather crude form of "bait and switch." Presumably most ads using scantily clad women aren't actually selling scantily clad women, they're selling some form of product that isn't a scantily clad woman. It's kind of like "ignore all rational thought about our product, and just follow the bouncing boobs."
There's nothing wrong with scantily clad women. There's nothing wrong with scantily clad women in games. There's something wrong with the many advertising campai
Re:Heh... Nice choice of ads... (Score:1)
Re:Heh... Nice choice of ads... (Score:2)
they may be not be offended, but they don't usually get aroused either(the bikini girls are damn well focused on male audience)... not to mention that if boobs are the only thing in it, whats the point? it's the internet for christsakes! there's boobs everywhere.
btw, add some ultra sarcastic black humour...
Re:Heh... Nice choice of ads... (Score:2)
Re:Heh... Nice choice of ads... (Score:2)
You have to understand, that every single ad for Anarchy Online I have every seen online was basically "scantily clad woman with Anarchy Online logo" with absolutely nothing to really sell me to the game except the scantily clad woman.
In fact, I can only guess that it's based on some sort of sci-fi setting soley because there appears to be a spaceship in the background, I actually don't know. The ads have told me nothing about what Anarchy Online is. (I suppose, on looking closer now, that the text "the
Re:Heh... Nice choice of ads... (Score:1)
All the ads showed was a very pretty lady with a tattoo that said "Forsaken" in front of a desolate background. Various ads would show various parts of her body (face, tummy, and so on). I'm sure you could google the ads if you felt like it. IIRC, even the box for the game showed the For
Re:Heh... Nice choice of ads... (Score:2)
And this might be a reason why, even after finding images of the game on Amazon.com and remembering the ads, I could not have told you anything about it. Those type of marketing campaigns don't work if you don't also provide information about what the product is. It might draw attention to the ad, but that's about it.
Sex alone doesn't sell anything... A sexy girl playing the game might help sell the game (which is probably Ubisoft's hope), but just a sexy girl and nothing else but the title doesn't qui
Re:Heh... Nice choice of ads... (Score:2)
This is a recurring argument of the form "If I wanted X then I would do Y, which contains X in a very concentrated form, why would anyone want Z which has much less?" The answer is some people like X, but will get in trouble with their parents or wives or their own sense of self-respect so they want it at a low concentration in another format that may have other redeeming qualities.
Re:Heh... Nice choice of ads... (Score:2)
It's the Internet. I'm sure you can find something out there to satisfy the need that isn't an ad for an MMORPG. Besides, as I mentioned in another post, other MMORPGs have cuter character models to oggle at anyway. :P
What a coincidence (Score:2)
Re:What a coincidence (Score:1)
Re:What a coincidence (Score:2)
Re:What a coincidence (Score:1)
Why are there *only* attractive females in the group? Surely there's some trollish females out there with mad 733+ gaming skillz.
Then again, you probably think drinking Bud Light will get you all the women as well...
Re:What a coincidence (Score:2)
"What a coincidence. All of them have good skin, large boobs, and fairly trim wastes. Am I the only one who thinks there is at least a bit of Milli Vanilli or Backstreet Boys to this group?"
You said they are attractive, then implied their skills are fake. Although you didn't outright say "they are attractive so they obviously aren't real gamers" it was pretty clear it was what you were getting at. This is just plain ignorance about their group.
"Do they have anything to do with girl
Re:What a coincidence (Score:3, Insightful)
But this is very different from most other clans and other FPS teams. Most clans and FPS teams aren't a marketing campaign
It really seems like this is a Marketing Campaign-- a "New Kids on the Block" kind of clan.
Ubisoft wanted a guerilla advertising campaign targeted at young male gamers, so they hired 8 pretty girls to form a clan. It's not very authentic. Using sex to advertise a product is all too common.
Re:What a coincidence (Score:2)
Re:What a coincidence (Score:4, Insightful)
I'm sure these women can play games and that they are pretty decent, but it's pretty obvious that the concept of the 'Frag Dolls' is a PR campaign first, and a gaming clan second.
It's about attracting male gamers to the Ubisoft product line. They are booth babes who are good at video games. It's manufactured group, just like the Bud girls and Britany Spears. They are using sex to manipulate you.
If the FragDolls were about Gaming first, and marketing second. then you might see more pictures of the ladies playing games, instead of sitting there looking pretty. Do you even see a video game in this lady's profile [fragdolls.com]? What does her eye and hair color have to do with her gaming ability?
Re:What a coincidence (Score:1)
Favorite Game Genres: MMORPG, RPG, and Action
Favorite Games: Shadowbane, EverQuest, Splinter Cell, Final Fantasy VII, Baldur's Gate II, KOTOR
Re:What a coincidence (Score:3, Insightful)
My bad.
I'm sure she plays video games, but the focus is on her good looks and curly red hair. If this is truely about video games, then where are the action shots of her playing video games?
Re:What a coincidence (Score:2)
Re:What a coincidence (Score:1)
http://www.fragdolls.com/profile.php?doll=katsc
Well, there's one, anyway.
Re:What a coincidence (Score:2)
It's advertising.
Re:What a coincidence (Score:2)
Re:What a coincidence (Score:2)
"Am I the only one who thinks there is at least a bit of Milli Vanilli or Backstreet Boys to this group? Do they have anything to do with girls in gaming,
You are implying that they aren't really playing their own games are you not? Because Milli Vanilli and the Backstreet Boys lipsync their performances? What other analogy could there be there? Heck, that doesn't even matter, if you question whether or not they have anything to do with girls in gaming, you a
Re:What a coincidence (Score:4, Insightful)
While Milli Vanilli was indeed fake, the Backstreet Boys is a group of five talented singers (even if you don't like their music, you have to admit this) who were artifically brought together by corporate interests to appeal to the teeniebopper market. I think that was the main point that he was trying to make.
BTW, I have to wonder how much of their impressive win rate has to do with the unwashed nerds that they're playing against hyperventilating and screaming "OMG GURLZ!!!" How many games do they play where the opponents can't see each other?
Heck, that doesn't even matter, if you question whether or not they have anything to do with girls in gaming, you are directly saying they aren't gamers at all.
Not necessarily. I think it would be valid to suggest that the media (as well as the aforementioned corporate interests) isn't interested in this group because it's an example of girls in gaming, but because it's an example of hot girls in gaming. In other words, this doesn't really have anything to do with gamer girls in general.
Rob
Re:What a coincidence (Score:1)
it's possible that someday you or I could earn some scratch for fragging.
The only way I'd earn money fragging is the same way William Hung won money singing.
Actually... (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Actually... (Score:2)
Re:Actually... (Score:4, Interesting)
My mom used to believe that all behavior was nurture, and not nature, until she became a preschool teacher. 10 years of 3 and 4 year old boys turning absolutely everything into a gun and girls turning everything into a doll house kinda wears down those lofty notions. Even if it is still is nurture based on some really complex societal stuff, the practical upshot remains, an obvious behavior difference tied to gender.
I admit this is a totally subjective observation, but boys seem more drawn to clear cut competition with well defined winners and losers whereas while girls can be very competitive, it tends to be much more subtle and indirect. To me that's the most obvious reason video games seem so much more likely to appeal to men. "YOU LOSE" "YOU WIN" It just seems to be attached to an emotional hair trigger in the male pysche. Games that purposely defy that rigid convention are more likely to appeal to women in my opinion, The Sims being a fairly obvious example.
Corporate shills (Score:2, Insightful)
Bes
Re:Corporate shills (Score:1)
What's wrong with First-person Shooters on consoles?
Re:Corporate shills (Score:2)
Re:Corporate shills (Score:1, Informative)
Splinter Cell may be good (subjective) but there's no fucking way it should ever be anybody's favorite game of all time. Shit, it doesn't even make the top 100 lists. Ever. Making that claim is spurious enough without adding the fact that these people are being subsidized by Ubisoft to play games. If the check was big enough, I'm sure they'd say the Dukes of Hazzard game was their favorite game
Re:Corporate shills (Score:1)
Re:Corporate shills (Score:3, Insightful)
Having said that, I agree that it's pretty obvious that particular choice would seem rather heavily affected by their status as being sponsored by Ubisoft. But at least Splinter Cell is indeed actually a very good game, the true total shill would have promoted their most underperforming game. Heck, who's
Re:Corporate shills (Score:2)
Re:Corporate shills (Score:2)
When I think shill, I'm picturing the guy who is in coherts with the shell game guy on the street, basically a
Re:Corporate shills (Score:2)
When you're sponsored by Ubisoft and you tell the interviewer that your favorite game of all time is Splinter Cell, you lose any credibility as a serious gamer.
What you say may very well be true but I also rank Splinter Cell as one of the best titles I've ever played.
Just 'cuz someone likes a title you don't doesn't necessarily make them a shill.
Re:Corporate shills (Score:2)
"And the AC wrote in complete sentences, spelled everything correctly, and didn't call anybody a cocksucker. Your point?"
Uh oh. A grammar nazi.
I wrote:
"What you say may very well be true but I also rank Splinter Cell as one of the best titles I've ever played."
The AC replied:
"How many have you played? What are some of your other favorite games of all time? How many hours a day/week/month do you play games?"
Not only a grammar nazi but working the ad hominem simulta
Re:Corporate shills (Score:2)
Second: I found it convenient that Splinter Cell showed up on nearly all of their 'Favorite Game' lists. Apparently they all love their Sam Fisher!
I have a very accurate and sensitive bullshit meter. The stuff that these girls write doesn't come off as bullshit. However, I just can't believe that that many gamers who supposedly have a variety of tastes would list Splinter Cell as one of their all-time favorites. Splinter cell just *
Re:Corporate shills (Score:1)
Enjoy living out of some relative's garage/basement.
As well, the value of anyone's opinion is the same as the next. I'm free to state my belief that Mavis Beacon Teaches Typing is a better title than whatever your favourite first person shooter is, and you have no place in telling me that I'm wrong. (I
Re:Corporate shills (Score:1)
Re:Corporate shills (Score:1)
I suppose if you state your opinion about my opinion as an opinion and not as a fact. Then you are, in fact, using my own logic against me.
I think I'm safe against that in this thread though.
But do they have skill? (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:But do they have skill? (Score:1, Funny)
Compelling argument, isn't it?
It's Anarchy Online... (Score:3, Interesting)
A friend made this point (Score:3, Insightful)
Rob
Re:A friend made this point (Score:1)
There are lots of games out there who enjoy it but suck... could they have been lucky or am I just giving them a hard time because they're woman?
Re:A friend made this point (Score:2)
Re:A friend made this point (Score:2)
I hear the guys at Bungie aren't too shabby at this here Halo 2 game. Bungie came out 3-0 against the Frag Dolls but it was a close 3-0 (50-26, 50-49, 50-45) and not a total whomping.
Halo Humpday Challenge [bungie.net]
Fancy Website (Score:1)
Re:Fancy Website (Score:1)
PR (Score:2)
Frankly, I think its pretty telling that there ARE NO UGLY FRAG DOLLS. Real game girls run the gamut from 3-10 in terms of looks, and the fact that these are all near model hotness girls says a lot.
If anybody from Ubisoft is reading this, I will be taking this PR move into consideration next time I am in the market for a video game, or when a frie
These girls as role models? (Score:2, Insightful)
This makes me sad. Why? Let's take them at their word that they are great gamers and are "so visible". Then I'll take it on the other
Where does that leave us girl gamers? I'll tell you where -- in yet another area of interest where you have to not only be good at what you do but you also h
Re:These girls as role models? (Score:2)
Personally, I like intelligent, chess-playing, beer-drinking girls, and I've found that I am very, very attracted by 'quirky'-looking females. A cute face with a playful gleam in the eye, perhaps a few freckles and a cute smile is infinitely more attractive than the IMO boring standard "look at me, I'm a model" look.
I'm sure I share this preference with many, many other geeks.
Don't
Re:These girls as role models? (Score:1)
Hail to the Geeks!
Re:These girls as role models? (Score:1)
Re:These girls as role models? (Score:1)
My "sadness" was for for the state of affairs: Gaming companies feeling that to sponsor a female team the members of said team would have to be good gamers AND be of Booth Babe looks. If anyone should be "role models" it should be females like yourself.
Re:These girls as role models? (Score:1)
Re:These girls as role models? (Score:1)
Re:These girls as role models? (Score:2)
Now, if only I could find a geeky, funky, chess-playin', beer-drinkin' girlfriend for myself...
She's got to be out there somewhere, waiting. I hope.
amateurs (Score:2)
Katscratch: depends on if we are in competition mode or not. Now we are practicing 3-5 times a week together
Rhoulette: It depends, but we try to get up to 10 hours of team practice in a week.
3-5 times a week, for a total of 10 hours? and they are supposedly competitve gamers? weaksauce. i play games pretty much daily, and on a slow saturday i can put in 10 hours on that day alone.
hmm, looks like all i need is a bra, a box of tissues, a blonde wig and
Re:amateurs (Score:2)
The amusing thing is what caught my attention about her. She lists Perl as one of her obsessions (that and her music and movies lists. It's pretty safe to say that she actually is a geek).
dateing (Score:1)
Hmmm (Score:1)
We have the Fragdolls, an obviously corporate tossed together group of women who seem to be decent gamers (and of course, eye candy).
They're in the 18 - under 30 age range, probably have student loans, etc to pay off, know their looks won't last forever and have been tossed together into a corporate sponsored clan.
It's easy for people to post (Corporate whore!1!!!111) and say they wouldn't take the money to be Ubisoft's marketing eye candy (something akin to BoothBabe+).
Let's face it, marketing has do