Please create an account to participate in the Slashdot moderation system

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×
China United States

Hundreds of Americans Planted 'Chinese Mystery Seeds' (vice.com) 166

An anonymous reader shares a report from Motherboard, written by Jason Koebler: In late July, America was briefly enthralled with "Unsolicited Seeds from China," which started showing up in mailboxes in all 50 states. These mystery seeds prompted warnings from the USDA, which said people should not plant them, and should instead alert their state agricultural authority and mail them to the USDA or their local officials. Many Americans heeded this advice. Many more decidedly did not. According to documents obtained by Motherboard from state departments of agriculture, at least hundreds, perhaps thousands of Americans planted the seeds. Since the seed story originally broke, I have been obsessed with learning more. To do this, I filed 52 freedom of information requests; one with each of the departments of agriculture (or their state-level equivalent) in all 50 states plus Washington DC and Puerto Rico. I also filed requests with the USDA and several of its labs. Thousands of pages of emails, spreadsheets, reports, and documents, as well as audio voicemail recordings, have been trickling in for the last month, and they have been enlightening in many ways.

While scanning through thousands of pages of documents about the seeds, it became clear that, for at least the first few weeks, no one had any idea who sent the seeds, where they came from (other than "China"), or the goal of the seed mailing campaign. Eventually, the official line became that this was a "brushing" campaign, in which items of small value are sent to people whose online accounts have been compromised, or are sent to people as a "gift." In order to leave a positive review from a "verified buyer" (which is weighted higher because the person nominally bought and used the product), you need to have actually bought or received an item, so by receiving seeds, reviews from that account or name will be weighted higher. The "brushing" idea is still what USDA and other agencies are saying, but, at least in the emails I've reviewed there's very little talk about how the scam worked or why it happened. This campaign also seems to be much larger than any other known brushing campaign or any other seed mailing campaign.

One thing is clear to me, from reading these documents. American people do not seem particularly well-prepared for scams of this nature. The emails between public officials and scientists, who were dealing with a difficult situation, seem efficient, professional, and appropriately cautious. But communication from the general public is concerning. People planted seeds even when expressly told not to. Hundreds of people had no idea whether they had ever ordered seeds, or how to check. Some people called 911. Others ate the seeds. Others ordered something specific, got what they ordered from who they ordered it from, then still panicked. Others were furious they had to pay for postage to send the seeds to the government. From one recipient in North Carolina: "I did not receive seeds. I received a suspicious package from China with a spoon and a fork in it my concerns are that it is full of Covid."

This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Hundreds of Americans Planted 'Chinese Mystery Seeds'

Comments Filter:
  • Comment removed based on user account deletion
    • What's with Japan and crazy plants? We have a kudzu problem in my state. The stuff can grow so fast you can almost see it happen.

      • Re:Invasive species (Score:4, Informative)

        by damn_registrars ( 1103043 ) <damn.registrars@gmail.com> on Friday September 11, 2020 @10:22AM (#60495666) Homepage Journal

        What's with Japan and crazy plants? We have a kudzu problem in my state. The stuff can grow so fast you can almost see it happen.

        Kudzu can only grow in certain ecosystems, and some in the US are too tough for it. I know of a weed brought over here on purpose a long time ago by Europeans that is decimating the landscape but gets nowhere near enough attention:

        • Garlic Mustard

        I've see this weed all the way up to - and likely across - the Canadian border now. It tends to sprout up on the edge of the forest but can take root damned near anywhere. It has exactly zero natural predators on this continent because nothing that lives here recognizes it as food. It also actively partakes in chemical warfare in the soil, creating soil that is not conducive to life for the plants that were there beforehand. It can spread by seed or root, and it is one of the fastest growing non-trees in the spring (easily reaching 3-4 feet by April in many places).

        The only advantage we have against it is that it has no thorns, does not cause allergic reactions for most people, and has a weak root system - in other words any person of even below-average strength can easily rip it out by hand without protection when they see it (my 5 year old can rip it out no problem).

        In other words don't pin it all on the Japanese, we Europeans have fucked it up pretty well here as well.

        • by syn3rg ( 530741 )

          Garlic Mustard

          It's also edible, so bon appetit!

          • Garlic Mustard

            It's also edible, so bon appetit!

            Indeed it is, but there is too much growing in my area for interested people to eat it all even if they tried. I really like the idea a group had for a pull and pesto contest [cromwellvalleypark.org] and I've considered trying to further it in my area in a future (non-pandemic) year.

        • by weeboo0104 ( 644849 ) on Friday September 11, 2020 @11:42AM (#60495960) Journal

          You can't fool me! I've seen enough Japanese anime to know how dangerous those plants are to girls in short skirts!

        • by jbengt ( 874751 )

          Garlic Mustard

          That's a problem in the parks and forest preserves around here.

          The only advantage we have against it is that it has no thorns, does not cause allergic reactions for most people, and has a weak root system

          Buckthorn is the invasive plant that's causing me problems in my yard. It has thorns, and has an aggressively spreading root system from which new shoots sprout, meaning if you remove a plant, it's likely only a small part of the organism, and you almost never get the whole root.

    • Knotweed is nowhere near as bad as its made out, we had some. Yes it can destroy concrete and walls - left to its own devices - but so can many plants given time. Have you seen what an oak tree can do? And even grass can grow through tiny cracks in concrete. It certainly does grow fast , but at the end of the day its just a type of bamboo and they all do and its just as susceptable to glyphosate as other weeds. It took standard glyphosate and 2 summers to kill our outbreak (created by neighbours dumping cra

      • Botanically, Japanese knotweed is not a bamboo, belonging to the grass family (Poaceae, monocot), but instead it belongs to the buckwheat family (Polygonaceae, dicot), as do buckwheat, rhubarb and sorrels (who do look a lot like grasses). I can't let misinformation about plants to propagate! Then giant knotweed [wikipedia.org] may be even worse than Japanese knotweed.
        • by Viol8 ( 599362 )

          Well whatever it is, its not the aggressive invader its made out to be, its just a fast growing plant. Leave it for months and yes it'll become a problem , spray it as soon as you see any shoots appear and it won't.

        • by Xest ( 935314 )

          "I can't let misinformation about plants to propagate!"

          I can't tell if this is some kind of botanist joke or not :)

    • by Pascoea ( 968200 )

      these people will probably learn their lesson the hard way.

      You've got way more faith in humanity than I do. It never ceases to amaze me how people will do dumb shit, consequences be damned.

    • ... and these people will probably learn their lesson the hard way.

      I wish that was the case, but apparently "learning" is not something these people do.

      These people are the reason that hairdryers have a label telling you not to use them in the shower.

  • by AndyKron ( 937105 ) on Friday September 11, 2020 @09:10AM (#60495352)
    The first thing I would do if I got mystery seeds from China would be to eat them. I also like turtles.
  • by the_skywise ( 189793 ) on Friday September 11, 2020 @09:11AM (#60495358)

    The seeds quickly grew into pods which cloned the body of the planters, assuming their personae and killing the original - thus causing CCP infiltration!

  • by timeOday ( 582209 ) on Friday September 11, 2020 @09:14AM (#60495378)
    I got the seeds. I didn't plant them but I thought the 'warnings' against doing so were poorly done, because they didn't provide any reason for it. Just some sort of generalized xenophobia.
    • Thats because it was not sinister. They were random seeds. The most likely theory to date is that the recipients had compromised amazon accounts and those amazon accounts were used to post fake reviews. It works in this manner

      1. Use compromised amazon account to order some product ensuring the payment and email notifications are done in a way that the real account holder is unaware of the transaction.
      2. Mail seeds instead of actual products since the cost of misc seeds is nothing compared to the actual prod

      • by Nidi62 ( 1525137 )

        Thats because it was not sinister. They were random seeds. The most likely theory to date is that the recipients had compromised amazon accounts and those amazon accounts were used to post fake reviews. It works in this manner

        1. Use compromised amazon account to order some product ensuring the payment and email notifications are done in a way that the real account holder is unaware of the transaction.

        They don't even have to have compromised accounts. The sellers can create fake accounts with real addresses gleaned from data breaches, and their own (or possibly stolen) payment info, buy their own products from their fake accounts, then leave verified reviews of the product they are trying to sell (which, as you noted, the seeds were sent in their place).

  • by 1s44c ( 552956 ) on Friday September 11, 2020 @09:20AM (#60495400)

    What were the seeds? Vegetables, flowers, something else?

    • Exactly. Wth is this still a mystery? They should have some germinating in a lab but experts at a local U should be able to narrow it way down just from the seeds.

      If these got into the wild, would it be evil, or just another flower or tuber?

    • At least one story I read said that one of the packets was some sort of Chinese melon. Harmless, but they made the guy destroy the plant anyway just in case. I'm guessing most of these are probably going to be random Asian vegetable seeds. If this is really part of a Brushing scam then they're going to send people stuff they already have on hand, they're not going to go out and purposely collect noxious invasive weed seeds. Then again, if it's something more sinister then I suppose they could go out and
      • If this is really part of a Brushing scam then they're going to send people stuff they already have on hand, they're not going to go out and purposely collect noxious invasive weed seeds.

        On the other hand, if they send the seeds to a different ecosystem, what they have at hand on their side of the globe may be harmless there, but invasive somewhere else. And several coman garden flowers are poisenous. So if I send some common seeds like for lily of the valley to someone with kids and they plant it, it may be fatal.

        • Breaking Bad reference? Nice.

          I remember hearing this rising panic when it started, but never really got how it needed to be anything more than, "I didn't order this. Meh." And either return to sender or destroy the seeds. I feel like we Americans have our panic levels so high in general that every little thing now causes some big row. Just seems ridiculous that this is still being stirred around as if it was something that truly matters.

          • Breaking Bad reference? Nice.

            Not intentional. Never watched it.

            I feel like we Americans have our panic levels so high in general that every little thing now causes some big row.

            And I blame social media for that. Everyone hopes that he will have that one post that goes viral and post about everything and nothing. And then - big surprise - the post about mystery seeds are shared more often than the latest lunch picture.

            • Breaking Bad reference? Nice.

              Not intentional. Never watched it.

              It played a big part in the story for a bit where a kid was poisoned with it.

              I feel like we Americans have our panic levels so high in general that every little thing now causes some big row.

              And I blame social media for that. Everyone hopes that he will have that one post that goes viral and post about everything and nothing. And then - big surprise - the post about mystery seeds are shared more often than the latest lunch picture.

              I'd say it's actually a combination of social media and big media. I mean, big media spent years attempting to get us riled up about every little thing. The number of "How is your home trying to kill you? Tune in at ten to find out!" commercials I saw over the years is mind boggling. Then the figured out that social media somehow grabs people's attention and switched to literally grabbing the most passed around stories online a

    • by Nidi62 ( 1525137 )

      What were the seeds? Vegetables, flowers, something else?

      Yes. From one website:

      They include mustard seeds, cabbage, morning glory, rose, hibiscus, and mint

      Probaby some scam sellers decided sending random seeds would be cheaper and easier than sending the real products for the fake reviews.

      • Which seems bizarre to me -- if I was conducting a scam in China, odds are I would be living in an urban area where actual plant seeds would be more obnoxious to come by than some other, light, easy to ship product, like say, plastic beads or some other plastic doohicky. Hell, you could probably find some random plastics factory willing to drop-ship the product for you.

        I'm just kind of surprised that *seeds* turned out to be the easiest item for whoever did this to ship. Maybe it was just a case of the sc

        • by vux984 ( 928602 )

          Or they could have been expired or nearly expired, (seeds have a shelf life of a few years), so they were probably free... or even doing someone a favor by getting rid of them.

          They could have sent empty envelopes and it would have met the requirements for a 'brushing campaign'... but it makes sense they'd stuff them with something on hand they got for free that was light enough that the postage would still the minunum. Empty envelopes would probably get more attention -- at least seeds could be explained a

        • by Pembers ( 250842 )

          Maybe this scam has been going on for years, and the only reason we've noticed now is that seeds suddenly became cheaper than whatever they were shipping before. (Someone's brother-in-law had a few trucks full of them that he needed to dispose of in a hurry?)

    • I know it doesn't happen around here, but if you scroll to the end of the linked vice article, it tells you.
  • First they send packets of seeds to gauge the reaction. Next it will be unsolicited "chinese" 5G routers.
    Or maybe the seeds grow into plants that will eavesdrop on your WiFi?
  • by Miser ( 36591 ) on Friday September 11, 2020 @09:28AM (#60495442)

    People are idiots. Coronavirus sure has proven that.

    That people would plant or event EAT (JFC ....) seeds of unknown provenance that weren't specifically ordered by them just takes the cake.

    To quote that maître d' from "Ferris Bueller's Day Off"

    I weep for the future

  • by jellomizer ( 103300 ) on Friday September 11, 2020 @09:29AM (#60495454)

    Ok I get it.
    1. This is a scam for the seller to give themselves higher ranking.
    2. The USDA really should know what foreign plants we are planing. As it could mess up the ecosystem.

    However I feel the burden of responsibility should go towards Amazon. They are OKing a purchase of Seeds from one country to another seeming to avoid customs. Yes it is a different seller, however if you are using Amazon as your marketplace, Amazon should have ultimate responsibility on what it sells.

    Now other than who should be blamed. How bad is the damage really? Are the plants evasive. or will they be eaten up by bugs, and die off from American Climates before they can reproduce.

    • by Nidi62 ( 1525137 ) on Friday September 11, 2020 @09:41AM (#60495498)

      However I feel the burden of responsibility should go towards Amazon. They are OKing a purchase of Seeds from one country to another seeming to avoid customs.

      Most likely, Amazon thinks the products being shipped are something else. The sellers are just sending the seeds instead of the actual products because seeds are cheap, plentiful, and small/light(so extra cheap shipping). They assume that the "customer" received the product being ordered, and since the person at that address didn't actually order it so there is no order number to report, the seller gets away with it. Meanwhile, the shippers are posting verified reviews under the fake account linked to that real address.

      • Still I see the responsibility to be on Amazon.

        Many of today's big Companies are making money off of selling products in which they have not invested into any controls on them.

        If a shipper shipped bad or dangerous product to Walmart, and Walmart stocked and sold them. They are responsible to what they have sold. Thus will need to take back items on their own dime. They may choose legal actions to the vendor to get their money back, but that is later.

        If the seller is "Selling" illegal or dangerous product

      • by Pembers ( 250842 )

        Most likely, Amazon thinks the products being shipped are something else.

        TFA says at least some of the packets were labelled as "stud earrings". I assume US Customs opens or X-rays a random selection of incoming packets and rejects any where the contents isn't as described. I wonder if the scammer actually sells stud earrings, or if they just put that on the label because (they thought) the seeds would look like stud earrings on an X-ray?

    • Chances are good that the "product" sold on Amazon was something other than seeds. The seeds were probably just what the seller shipped when they "sold" that product to the fake account with that address.
  • The summary says, "American people do not seem particularly well-prepared for scams of this nature." My question is, exactly why should I be prepared for a scam of this nature? I have yet to see anything suggesting that the recipients of these seeds were in risk of anything more than having unwanted plants growing in their garden (a risk which is easily avoided by not planting the seeds).
    • I have yet to see anything suggesting that the recipients of these seeds were in risk of anything more than having unwanted plants growing in their garden (a risk which is easily avoided by not planting the seeds).

      Apparently it's not that easy, because some people did plant the seeds.

      Planting unknown seeds is by definition a risk. It's not as serious as some other risks, but that doesn't make it not a risk. It can cause real problems. Maybe not cataclysm-level problems, but that doesn't make them not problems.

      • Perhaps the people who planted the seeds were curious about what would grow, perhaps a significant fraction of them chose to plant the seeds in a location which would not cause them any problems if the plants which grew were undesirable.

        It's not like this packages of seeds arrived with a message suggesting that planting them would accomplish some noble goal (I remember a few years ago some organization when asking people to sign up to receive wild flower seeds to be planted in order to help various wild b
    • by Ichijo ( 607641 )

      Why should people be prepared for scams? Because there are a lot of bad people out there who want to separate you from your money.

      Let me tell you about an acquaintance of mine. He's a conspiracy nut, the kind of person who will believe anything you say if you make it sound like a conspiracy. In a word, "gullible."

      He's also the type who worships people of wealth, power, and authority, including our men in green and blue. I think by now you can guess his political affiliation.

      So one day he got a call from the

      • Well, that is a scam of a completely different nature and yes, people should be prepared for scams of that nature. But why should they need to be prepared for scams which involve receiving something they did not request, and which will not cost them any money?

        It's not like these seeds arrived with some message asking the person to plant them for some supposedly noble purpose.
        • by Ichijo ( 607641 )

          Whether it's a scam of a different nature is, like, your opinion, man. I tend to be wary of anything unsolicited until I understand what's in it for the other person. Isn't that a useful thing to teach kids?

  • Seriously, how were all those seeds let into the USA? Where were the customs inspections?

    I would not be surprised if a lot of very invasive species were sent to the USA. This won't end well.

  • If I had received them I would have been sorely tempted to set up an isolated place in my basement with grow lights to plant them just to see what they are. Have any of the ones that were planted produced anything yet? I presume nobody is willing to pay to have the seeds' DNA sequenced to get a more definitive answer.
  • The packages were send without tracking. I don't understand why you have to send something at all. 1. Create orders and cash flow via Amazon, IF (big if) Amazon was used. You pay for your own orders 2. Wait, post review. Some newspapers posted pictures of the letters. They were send. 1. Without tracking 2. From China and not from an Amazon warehouse. So this does not make sense at all. If you send without tracking, why send at all? Nobody is going to complain since you paid yourself and gave Amazon it
  • ... the new kudzu takes hold in the U.S.

  • This is clearly the work of El Seed [thetick.ws].

  • No. (Score:4, Insightful)

    by argStyopa ( 232550 ) on Friday September 11, 2020 @11:12AM (#60495834) Journal

    "One thing is clear to me, from reading these documents. American people do not seem particularly well-prepared for scams of this nature. "

    I'm an American, so believe me when I say that the one thing that's clear is that people - in this case Americans, but I suspect it's a widespread affliction - are fucking idiots.

  • Millions of Americans eat mystery meat, a little seed can't make them afraid.

  • I have been getting packages from China containing two packs of sewing needles.
    I didn't order them, or anything like them, yet they have come every month, six times so far.
    I did not try to plant them.

  • by PPH ( 736903 )

    I sent you to the market to sell the cow. And all you brought back are these lousy beans.

  • Ah, so this is how the events in The Windup Girl begin.

    Oy. So dumb.

  • by Kitkoan ( 1719118 ) on Friday September 11, 2020 @12:14PM (#60496062)
    They are triffids seeds, they are trying to kill us all. Next thing you know there'll be a giant meteor shower....
  • Just cross your fingers, everyone, that they aren't some GMO seeds that'll wreck us ecologically.
    I don't even really give a flying fuck at this point. We've already set ourselves up as a species to kill ourselves off in at least half a dozen ways that we probably can't back out of now, what's one more way to get wrecked? I'll probably be dead before the end anyway.

Math is like love -- a simple idea but it can get complicated. -- R. Drabek

Working...