Ontario Science Center To Close Immediately Over Roof Collapse Risk (www.cbc.ca) 24
The Ontario Science Center, a world-class science and cultural institution in Toronto, is shutting down immediately due to the risk that the building's roof could collapse, the province announced Friday. CBC News: The abrupt closure, which the province says could last years, comes after the government's controversial announcement in 2023 that the popular landmark and attraction would be moved to the Ontario Place site -- a move it says will save costs. "The actions taken today will protect the health and safety of visitors and staff," said Infrastructure Minister Kinga Surma in a news release. "We are making every effort to avoid disruption to the public and help the Ontario Science Centre continue delivering on its mandate."
An engineering report this week by Rimkus Consulting Group showed each of the centre's three buildings contain roof panels in a "distressed, high-risk" condition, the Ministry of Infrastructure said in a news release. The panels require fixing by Oct. 31, 2024 to "avoid further stress due to potential snow load which could lead to roof panel failure," the release said. Fixing the roof will cost between $22 million and $40 million, the ministry said, requiring the centre be closed for up to two years. "These estimates are incomplete and subject to change," said the ministry, noting the costs make up only a "small portion" of the funding needed to keep the science centre open. The government says the centre needs $478 million to tackle its "failing infrastructure" and sustain programming.
An engineering report this week by Rimkus Consulting Group showed each of the centre's three buildings contain roof panels in a "distressed, high-risk" condition, the Ministry of Infrastructure said in a news release. The panels require fixing by Oct. 31, 2024 to "avoid further stress due to potential snow load which could lead to roof panel failure," the release said. Fixing the roof will cost between $22 million and $40 million, the ministry said, requiring the centre be closed for up to two years. "These estimates are incomplete and subject to change," said the ministry, noting the costs make up only a "small portion" of the funding needed to keep the science centre open. The government says the centre needs $478 million to tackle its "failing infrastructure" and sustain programming.
Trudeau (Score:2, Troll)
Bottom line, how can we blame Trudeau for this?
Re: (Score:2)
What does Doonesbury have to do with it?
Re: Trudeau (Score:2, Insightful)
Re: (Score:2)
Bottom line, how can we blame Trudeau for this?
ONTARIO Science Center - not under Trudeaus jurisdiction. It is under Premier Doug Fords however.
Re: (Score:1)
But we hate Trudeau. Everything is his fault, even if he has nothing to do with it.
Your toast fell butter side down? Trudeau's fault.
You spilled your coffee on your shirt? Trudeau's fault.
Step on a crack and broke your mother's back? Trudeau's fault.
Safety AND cost determined in one day? (Score:2)
Re: Safety AND cost determined in one day? (Score:2)
How does a roof replacement cost $22M-$40M?! (Score:2)
How does a roof replacement cost $22M-$40M?!
Something's wrong with this figure.
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:3)
If the roof is in imminent risk of collapse, that means there's a lot more wrong than just the waterproofing layer. We're talking a lot of girders and trusses here. A lot of engineering required. To say nothing about the cost of shoring and bracing so that workers can safely erect scaffolding to work inside the roof structure. Not surprised at all about the cost.
If your home had a roof that was at risk of collapse you would need a lot more than just new shingles!
Re:How does a roof replacement cost $22M-$40M?! (Score:4, Informative)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: How does a roof replacement cost $22M-$40M?! (Score:2)
The building was constructed for $23M ($169M today). It is basically a brutalist (concrete Soviet architectural style) government building, it was not meant to be maintained for this long, it is mostly a flat roof and a small area has a dome shape, so snow adds a huge load every winter. But given the construction, you basically have to cut the existing roof out and replace most of the building structural support, itâ(TM)s not just some shingles.
You could probably just demolish it and build a better arc
Re: (Score:2)
It is basically a brutalist (concrete Soviet architectural style) government building,
Sheesh! You really should take at least one look at a building before commenting on its architectural style. The complex shares nothing at all in common with a Soviet era office block (and BTW, the Brutalist movement Originated in the UK, not the USSR).
A long time coming, probably (Score:3)
I'm in my 50s. The OSC was a standard school trip for students in the Greater Toronto Area when I was a kid, and back then most of the exhibits worked. I took my kids a decade or so ago and it seems like most of the exhibits were broken - presumably the place was never properly funded after the initial setup.
It's a shame, it's an interesting building on beautiful property, and we really should have a nice practical science exhibit available to the population.
But the last time I wanted my kids to have that kind of experience, I drove 4 hours north to Sudbury and visited Science North. It's smaller, but it's in great condition and staffed by a bunch of young very enthusiastic people and we had a hell of a time there.
My understanding is the government wants to relocate the OSC to the old Ontario Place grounds. That wouldn't be the worst location, but Ontario Place isn't all that much newer so I question the viability of the plan. If you're going to do some kind of major reno, I think it'd be better to fix the existing location.
Once the best basic science museum in the world (Score:3)
Re:A long time coming, probably (Score:4, Informative)
It's a shame, it's an interesting building on beautiful property, and we really should have a nice practical science exhibit available to the population.
It IS a shame. And I bet Doug Frod, (intentional misspelling), is absolutely salivating at the prospect of selling that land to his developer buddies so they can build multi-million dollar homes on prime ravine land. After all, this IS the province that one wag defined as "three developers in a trench-coat, walking a Premier on a leash".
My understanding is the government wants to relocate the OSC to the old Ontario Place grounds. That wouldn't be the worst location, but Ontario Place isn't all that much newer so I question the viability of the plan.
I seem to remember that the plan for Ontario Place called for a much smaller building for the Science Centre, which would be part of an amusement park or some such nonsense. To provide parking for all this activity, the plan called for a parking garage. With two or three levels underground. On an artificial island in Lake Ontario. What could possibly go wrong with that plan?
It wouldn't surprise me in the least to hear that these morons are planning to build on the Leslie Street Spit.
Re: (Score:2)
>salivating at the prospect of selling that land to his developer buddies so they can build multi-million dollar homes on prime ravine land.
That was my assumption, but I assumed condo apartments.
Re: (Score:2)
Found it in today's news:
âoeThe reason heâ(TM)s doing this is to justify the $600-million parking lot (and) the Therme spa that weâ(TM)ll be building on public land,â Crombie said during the rally, referring to the provinceâ(TM)s Ontario Place redevelopment plans that feature a private, water-themed spa.
Re: (Score:2)
Re:A long time coming, definitely (Score:3)
Ontario stopped funding the science centre years ago, and let the main entrance bridge fall into disrepair. You now have to enter most of the building by the back door.
Raymond Moriyama, the world-famous architect, designed it "for the ages", so the bridge failure already made me wonder.
Then they cut the budget and laid off a bunch of exhibit designers.
Then Mr Ford, the Ontario Premier, announced they were going to shut it down in favour of a new space adjacent to a private spa at Ontario Place.
This w
My timing was good (Score:2)
My BF and I are in the Toronto area and went to OSC on Wednesday. I guess our timing was good.
It's too bad the building is in such disrepair. I have many great memories of visits there.
Schools and hospitals in the UK too (Score:2)
Many schools and hospitals in the UK were constructed with RAAC [bbc.co.uk] (Reinforced autoclaved aerated concrete). UK Government report [parliament.uk]