Darwin Among the Machines

Actually titled Darwin Among the Machines: The Evolution of Global Intelligence, this review of the George Dyson book was sent to us by Tal Cohen. To give a good idea about what the book is exploring, I believe that this quote from Dyson, the author is well suited: "In the game of life and evolution, there are three players at the table: human beings, nature, and machine. I am firmly on the side of nature, but nature, I suspect, is on the side of machines." Touted in intellectual circles, this book examines the convergence of man, nature and machine, and the ramifications as well as examining aspects of it within a well developed historical context. For more, click below.

Darwin Among the Machines: The Evolution of Global Intelligence
author	George B. Dyson
pages
publisher	Helix Books / Addison Wesley
rating	4/5
reviewer	Tal Cohen
ISBN	0-201-40649-7
summary

Could it possibly be that modern communication networks lead us to one of those rare crossroads between really far-fetched science-fiction and reality? In Darwin Among the Machines, George B. Dyson speculates that huge-scale non-human intelligence will inevitably evolve around us. In addition, the book is a refreshing history of both computing and evolution science.

Most scientist today believe that the human mind was never designed; it had evolved, slowly, over millions of generations. The main idea suggested by George Dyson in this book is simple: In the digital universe, too, a conscious mind will evolve naturally, rather than as the result of some design. Artificial Intelligence researches might as well spend their time searching for signs of intelligence on the net rather than try to develop it.

The book begins with a refreshing overview of the history of computing, as well as a brief history of the science of evolution -- with a glance towards the evolution of machines. The history of computing presented in the book is naturally biased towards issues that are relevant to the topic at hand, which is in fact an advantage, since it makes the history seem so much more refreshing.

It is a misconception, based on the stereotype of a Turing machine as executing a prearranged program one step at a time, to assume that Turing believed that any single, explicitly programmed serial process would ever capture human intelligence in mechanical form. Turing knew how many interconnected neurons it took to make a brain, and he knew how many brains it took to form a society that could kindle the spark of language and intelligence into flame.

Surprisingly for a book that deals with artificial life and intelligence, and in which Alan Turing is an important part of the cast, the infamous Turing Test for machine intelligence is hardly mentioned. Turing is not dealt with in the cliched way commonly found in other books on the subject. Rather, we are given a view of Turing as a serious researcher -- and as the first hacker-at-heart:

The IAS memory was based on the Williams tube -- an ordinary cathode-ray tube (CRT) modified to allow data to be read, written, and continuously refreshed as a pattern of charged spots on the phosphor coating inside the tube. [...] You could watch the bits of information dancing on the screen as a computation proceeded, and Turing, who soon joined the Manchester group, was noted for his ability to read numbers directly off the screen, just as he had been able to read binary code directly from teletypewriter tapes as intercepted messages were being sorted out.

Dyson quotes from sources, some surprisingly old, about the implications of the theory of evolution on the world of machines. Newer sources, of course, speak mainly about computers in this context; some of the older quotes in the book, however, date long before the computer was even conceived. In fact, even the book's title is a quote -- it was originally the title of an article published in 1863 by Samuel Butler. Such a substantial amount of text in the book is presented as direct quotes, that at times it creates the illusion that the book is nothing but a very-well done library research job. But do not be fooled: Dyson certainly presents bold new ideas.

Dyson's main claim is that the evolution of a conscious mind from today's technology is inevitable. It is not clear whether this will be a single mind or multiple minds, how smart that mind would be, and even if we will be able to communicate with it. He also clearly suggests that there are forms of intelligence on Earth that we are currently unable to understand.

What mind, if any, will become apprehensive of the great coiling of ideas now under way is not a meaningless question, but it is still too early in the game to expect an answer that is meaningful to us.

While Douglas Hofstadter, in Godel, Escher, Bach, had jokingly suggested an ant colony as a model of a mind, Dyson boldly states that insects have "socially distributed intelligence" (p. 174). He also suggests that human societies might actually form higher-level minds, in which humans take the part of neurons. And just as a neuron cannot possibly comprehend its role in the brain, so we can hardly expect a human the grasp his role in the greater mind that he is part of.

[It] is presumptuous to assume that artificial intelligence will operate on a level, or a time scale, that we are able to comprehend. As we merge toward collective intelligence, our own language and intelligence may be related to a subsidiary role or left behind. When the brass head speaks, there is no guarantee that it will speak in a language that we can understand.

With all the ideas Dyson relates regarding the inevitable appearance of intelligence over modern information networks, one might wonder if this hasn't already occurred. In his book Speaker for the Dead, science-fiction author Orson Scott Card suggested that when such an intelligence will emerge, it will be scared to let us know of its existence, knowing that some people, fearing anything nonhuman, will do their best to terminate it.

To buy this book head over to Amazon.

For more information about the book, please visit http://www.forum2.org/tal/books/darwin.html.

For additional book reviews, please visit http://www.forum2.org/tal/books.